Majda Anna, Majkut Michalina, Wróbel Aldona, Kamińska Alicja, Kurowska Anna, Wojcieszek Agata, Kołodziej Kinga, Barzykowski Krystian
Laboratory of Theory and Fundamentals of Nursing, Institute of Nursing and Midwifery, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jagiellonian University Medical College, Michałowskiego 12 Street, 31-126 Krakow, Poland.
Institute of Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Ingardena 6 Street, 30-060 Krakow, Poland.
Healthcare (Basel). 2024 Jan 3;12(1):115. doi: 10.3390/healthcare12010115.
Understanding the attitudes of medical staff contributes to shaping a culture of safety in health care. The aim of this study was the measurement of attitudes of nurses and midwives towards reporting clinical adverse events. Various research tools were used, including the Reporting of Clinical Adverse Events Scale (RoCAES; Polish: P-RoCAES), the Justice Sensitivity Inventory, the Feelings in Moral Situations Scale, the Perceived Stress at Work Scale and the Author's Survey Questionnaire. The cross-sectional survey was conducted from October 2022 to April 2023. The study used assessment-based sampling. The study included 745 midwives and nurses working in internal medicine-surgical wards in nine hospitals in a large provincial city in Poland. One-way analysis of variance ANOVA, post hoc test (Fisher's NIR), and r-Spearman correlation test were used. The level of significance () did not exceed 0.05. Respondents did not differ in terms of sensitivity to justice, moral feelings, and perceived stress at work, all of which variables were at moderate levels. Respondents' attitudes towards reporting clinical adverse events in the P-RoCAES were positive (surgical nurses 71.10; internal medicine nurses 72.04; midwives 71.26; F(2.741) = 1.14, = 0.319), especially those with a master's degree, longer work experience and older age. Respondents with a master's degree were most likely to perceive a benefit from reporting adverse events (P-RoCAES subscale) (F(2.737) = 8.45, = 0.001). The longer employment tenure (F(3.716) = 4.63, = 0.003) and having a master's degree (F(2.737) = 3.10, = 0.045) were associated with a higher feeling of guilt among the respondents (P-RoCAES subscale). The longer the participants worked, the more positive their attitude became towards the importance of transparency in procedures (F(2.741) = 3.56, = 0.029), but the more negative their attitude was towards the benefits of reporting adverse events (P-RoCAES subscale) (r(686) = -0.08, = 0.037). Individual attitudes of nurses and midwives as well as their age, length of service or education can influence the formation of a culture of safety in health care (including the reporting of clinical adverse events). Attitudes can motivate corrective action, can be reinforced and shaped by educational programs, good quality management and monitoring system solutions.
了解医护人员的态度有助于塑造医疗保健中的安全文化。本研究的目的是衡量护士和助产士对报告临床不良事件的态度。使用了各种研究工具,包括临床不良事件报告量表(RoCAES;波兰语:P-RoCAES)、正义敏感性量表、道德情境中的情感量表、工作压力感知量表和作者调查问卷。横断面调查于2022年10月至2023年4月进行。该研究采用基于评估的抽样方法。该研究包括波兰一个大城市九家医院内科-外科病房工作的745名助产士和护士。使用了单因素方差分析、事后检验(Fisher's NIR)和r-斯皮尔曼相关检验。显著性水平()不超过0.05。受访者在正义敏感性、道德情感和工作压力感知方面没有差异,所有这些变量都处于中等水平。受访者在P-RoCAES中对报告临床不良事件的态度是积极的(外科护士71.10;内科护士72.04;助产士71.26;F(2.741)=1.14,=0.319),尤其是那些拥有硕士学位、工作经验较长和年龄较大的人。拥有硕士学位的受访者最有可能从报告不良事件(P-RoCAES子量表)中感知到益处(F(2.737)=8.45,=0.001)。较长的工作年限(F(3.716)=4.63,=0.003)和拥有硕士学位(F(2.737)=3.10,=0.045)与受访者较高的内疚感(P-RoCAES子量表)相关。参与者工作时间越长,他们对程序透明度重要性的态度就越积极(F(2.741)=3.56,=0.029),但他们对报告不良事件益处的态度就越消极(P-RoCAES子量表)(r(686)=-0.08,=0.037)。护士和助产士的个人态度以及他们的年龄、服务年限或教育程度会影响医疗保健中安全文化的形成(包括临床不良事件的报告)。态度可以激励采取纠正措施,可以通过教育项目、优质管理和监测系统解决方案得到强化和塑造。