Nantakool Sothida, Punturee Khanittha, Konghakote Supatcha, Sitthichoke Cattaleeya, Phirom Kochaphan, Chuatrakoon Busaba
Environmental-Occupational Health Sciences and Non Communicable Diseases Research Center, Research Institute for Health Sciences, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50200, Thailand.
Center Research Unit of Associated Medical Sciences (AMS-CRU), Faculty of Associated Medical Sciences, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50200, Thailand.
J Clin Med. 2023 Dec 21;13(1):44. doi: 10.3390/jcm13010044.
Among obesity, cumulative fat and poor physical activity are risk factors for cardiovascular disease. Due to the limit in performing aerobic exercise (AER), whole-body vibration (WBV) as a passive form of exercise is an alternative therapeutic strategy. Herein, this study aimed to compare the immediate effects of AER and WBV on metabolic and cardiovascular responses, and dyspnea level in obesity. Forty-nine eligible obesities performed both AER and WBV, with a random order assignment (age = 28.94 ± 11.39 years). Fat oxidation, cardiovascular parameters (i.e., heart rate (HR) and blood pressure (BP)), and dyspnea level (i.e., rating perceived exertion (RPE)) were measured during exercise, while lipid mobilization (i.e., triglycerides) was collected pre- and post-exercise. Fat oxidation rate in AER was significantly higher than in WBV. Significantly increased fat oxidation rates were shown in both groups (within-group analyses) (also shown in females aged 20-45). Triglyceride levels between AER and WBV were similar. A significant decrease in triglyceride levels was only observed in WBV (within-group change). HR and RPE in AER were significantly higher than in WBV ( < 0.05). HR and RPE were significantly increased throughout both AER and WBV, while systolic blood pressure was only significantly elevated in AER (whining-group analyses). WBV may facilitate fat oxidation (particularly in females aged below 45), induce lipid mobilization, and reduce interference on cardiovascular parameters in obesity.
在肥胖人群中,累积脂肪和缺乏体育锻炼是心血管疾病的危险因素。由于进行有氧运动(AER)存在限制,全身振动(WBV)作为一种被动运动形式是一种替代治疗策略。在此,本研究旨在比较有氧运动和全身振动对肥胖人群代谢、心血管反应及呼吸困难程度的即时影响。49名符合条件的肥胖者进行了有氧运动和全身振动,采用随机顺序分组(年龄 = 28.94 ± 11.39岁)。在运动期间测量脂肪氧化、心血管参数(即心率(HR)和血压(BP))以及呼吸困难程度(即主观用力程度分级(RPE)),同时在运动前和运动后采集脂质动员指标(即甘油三酯)。有氧运动中的脂肪氧化率显著高于全身振动。两组均显示脂肪氧化率显著增加(组内分析)(20 - 45岁女性中也有此现象)。有氧运动和全身振动之间的甘油三酯水平相似。仅在全身振动中观察到甘油三酯水平显著下降(组内变化)。有氧运动中的心率和主观用力程度分级显著高于全身振动(<0.05)。在有氧运动和全身振动过程中,心率和主观用力程度分级均显著增加,而收缩压仅在有氧运动中显著升高(组内分析)。全身振动可能有助于脂肪氧化(特别是在45岁以下女性中),诱导脂质动员,并减少对肥胖人群心血管参数的干扰。