Pilard Claire-Marie, Villemain Olivier, Laforest Gérald, Roubertie François, Thambo Jean-Benoit, Jalal Zakaria
Department of Paediatric and Adult Congenital Cardiology, Bordeaux University Hospital, 36000 Pessac, France.
Plateforme Technologique d'Innovation Biomédicale, Centre de Recherche Cardio-Thoracique de Bordeaux, Bordeaux University, INSERM U1045, 33600 Pessac, France.
J Clin Med. 2023 Dec 29;13(1):198. doi: 10.3390/jcm13010198.
Secundum atrial septal defects (sASDs) are common congenital cardiac defects mostly treated using a transcatheter approach. However, small children (<15 kg) are still undergoing surgical sASD closure in many centres. Although both options have been proved to have excellent results in children, comparative data of the two techniques are missing for patients ≤ 15 kg. The medical records of children ≤ 15 kg who underwent sASD surgical (group A) and transcatheter (group B) closure between 2010 and 2023 were reviewed retrospectively. Twenty-five children in group A and twenty-two in group B were included (mean weight 8.9 kg in group A and 10.3 kg in group B). The main indications for closure were right heart enlargement and failure to thrive. Major complications occurred in two patients in group A and none in group B. Minor complications occurred in eight patients in group A and one in group B. At last follow-up, symptoms resolved completely or improved significantly for all infants, with the exception of failure to thrive in the sub-population of children with extra-cardiac comorbidities. sASD closure can be performed safely in symptomatic infants ≤ 15 kg, even in the presence of comorbidity, and should not be postponed. However, in patients with extra-cardiac comorbidities, the only indication of growth retardation must be carefully evaluated.
继发孔型房间隔缺损(sASD)是常见的先天性心脏缺陷,大多采用经导管方法治疗。然而,许多中心仍在对低体重儿童(<15kg)进行sASD手术闭合。虽然这两种方法在儿童中均已被证明效果良好,但对于体重≤15kg的患者,两种技术的对比数据仍缺失。我们回顾性分析了2010年至2023年间接受sASD手术闭合(A组)和经导管闭合(B组)的体重≤15kg儿童的病历。A组纳入25例儿童,B组纳入22例儿童(A组平均体重8.9kg,B组平均体重10.3kg)。闭合的主要指征是右心扩大和生长发育迟缓。A组有2例患者发生主要并发症,B组无主要并发症发生。A组有8例患者发生轻微并发症,B组有1例发生轻微并发症。在最后一次随访时,除合并心脏外疾病的儿童亚组中存在生长发育迟缓外,所有婴儿的症状均完全缓解或显著改善。对于有症状的体重≤15kg婴儿,即使存在合并症,sASD闭合也可安全进行,不应推迟。然而,对于合并心脏外疾病的患者,必须仔细评估生长发育迟缓这一唯一指征。