Centre for Sport Research, Deakin University, Burwood, VIC, Australia.
Mary MacKillop Institute for Health Research, Australian Catholic University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2024 Jan 11;34(2):111-121. doi: 10.1123/ijsnem.2023-0186. Print 2024 Mar 1.
The aim of this audit was to quantify female representation in research on heat adaptation. Using a standardized audit tool, the PubMed database was searched for heat adaptation literature from inception to February 2023. Studies were included if they investigated heat adaptation among female and male adults (≥18-50 years) who were free from noncommunicable diseases, with heat adaptation the primary or secondary outcome of interest. The number and sex of participants, athletic caliber, menstrual status, research theme, journal impact factor, Altmetric score, Field-Weighted Citation Impact, and type of heat exposure were extracted. A total of 477 studies were identified in this audit, including 7,707 participants with ∼13% of these being female. Most studies investigated male-only cohorts (∼74%, n = 5,672 males), with ∼5% (n = 360 females) including female-only cohorts. Of the 126 studies that included females, only 10% provided some evidence of appropriate methodological control to account for ovarian hormone status, with no study meeting best-practice recommendations. Of the included female participants, 40% were able to be classified to an athletic caliber, with 67% of these being allocated to Tier 2 (i.e., trained/developmental) or below. Exercise heat acclimation was the dominant method of heat exposure (437 interventions), with 21 studies investigating sex differences in exercise heat acclimation interventions. We recommend that future research on heat adaptation in female participants use methodological approaches that consider the potential impact of sexual dimorphism on study outcomes to provide evidence-based guidelines for female athletes preparing for exercise or competition in hot conditions.
本审计旨在量化女性在热适应研究中的代表性。使用标准化的审计工具,从建库到 2023 年 2 月,在 PubMed 数据库中搜索热适应文献。如果研究调查了成年女性和男性(≥18-50 岁)在无非传染性疾病的情况下的热适应,并且热适应是主要或次要关注的结果,则纳入研究。提取参与者的数量和性别、运动水平、月经状况、研究主题、期刊影响因子、Altmetric 得分、领域加权引文影响力以及热暴露类型。在本次审计中,共确定了 477 项研究,其中包括 7707 名参与者,其中约 13%为女性。大多数研究调查了仅男性队列(74%,n=5672 名男性),其中5%(n=360 名女性)包括仅女性队列。在纳入女性的 126 项研究中,只有 10%提供了一些适当的方法学控制证据,以说明卵巢激素状态,没有研究符合最佳实践建议。在所纳入的女性参与者中,有 40%能够被归类为运动水平,其中 67%被分配到第 2 层(即训练/发展)或以下。运动热适应是热暴露的主要方法(437 项干预措施),其中 21 项研究调查了运动热适应干预措施中的性别差异。我们建议,未来对女性参与者的热适应研究采用考虑性二态性对研究结果潜在影响的方法学方法,为准备在炎热条件下进行运动或比赛的女性运动员提供循证指南。