Moshaoa Mpule A L, Taunyane Keitumetse, Hlongwa Phumzile
Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.
Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Health SA. 2023 Dec 20;28:2442. doi: 10.4102/hsag.v28i0.2442. eCollection 2023.
Good record-keeping is fundamental in clinical practice and essential for practising dental practitioners and those in training.
This study aimed to evaluate the level of compliance with clinical record-keeping by undergraduate dental students and staff at a university dental hospital.
The selected study setting was the Admissions and Emergency section at a university dental hospital.
A retrospective, cross-sectional review was undertaken of 257 clinical records. The CRABEL scoring system was used to evaluate 12 variables. The 12 variables included: patient name, patient hospital number, date of examination, patient main complaint, medical history, dental history, proposed treatment, proposed procedure for next visit, patient consent signature, treatment and treatment codes, student name and signature, clinical supervisor name and signature. STATA® 13 was used for descriptive analysis and all tests were conducted at 5% significance level.
The median CRABEL score was 87 and interquartile range (IQR: 70-92). A CRABEL score of 100 was achieved by the students in the variable , indicating a 100% compliance with this variable. Other variables such as showed poor compliance. The CRABEL scores showed no statistically significant difference ( = 0.86) between the students and clinical supervisors.
The overall audit showed that there was poor compliance with record-keeping.
The study highlights the importance of good record keepings so that key information can be accessed for proper diagnosis and treatment of the patient. An electronic filing system presents an alternative manner of documenting medical records.
良好的记录保存是临床实践的基础,对于执业牙医和实习人员至关重要。
本研究旨在评估某大学牙科医院本科牙科学生和工作人员对临床记录保存的遵守程度。
选定的研究地点是某大学牙科医院的入院及急诊科室。
对257份临床记录进行回顾性横断面审查。采用CRABEL评分系统评估12个变量。这12个变量包括:患者姓名、患者医院编号、检查日期、患者主要诉求、病史、牙科病史、拟治疗方案、下次就诊拟采取的程序、患者同意签名、治疗及治疗代码、学生姓名及签名、临床督导姓名及签名。使用STATA® 13进行描述性分析,所有检验均在5%的显著性水平下进行。
CRABEL评分中位数为87,四分位间距(IQR:70 - 92)。学生在变量 中CRABEL评分为100,表明该变量的遵守率为100%。其他变量如 显示遵守情况较差。学生和临床督导之间的CRABEL评分无统计学显著差异( = 0.86)。
总体审核显示记录保存的遵守情况较差。
该研究强调了良好记录保存的重要性,以便获取关键信息用于患者的正确诊断和治疗。电子存档系统提供了一种记录医疗记录的替代方式。