Reznik Aleksandr M, Syunyakov Timur S, Mudrak Aleksandr V, Zakharov Nikolay B, Popova Zhanna B, Khoroshilova Anastasia N, Khurbatova Ilona G, Saifulina Alina M, Eliseenko Anton M, Matvievskaya Tatiana K, Khannanova Angelina N
Mental-health Clinic No. 1 named after N.A. Alexeev.
Russian Biotechnological University (ROSBIOTECH).
Consort Psychiatr. 2023 Mar 31;4(1):18-36. doi: 10.17816/CP3728.
Depression in patients with schizophrenia worsens the course of the disease by increasing the risk of suicide, by complicating the clinical picture of the disorder, and by reducing the quality of the social functioning; its treatment is difficult, since monotherapy, even when involving modern antipsychotics, does not always prove successful. While the prescription of additional antidepressants (ADs) can improve the likelihood of a better outcome, the effectiveness of such augmentation in many cases is yet to be proven. Therefore, it is still important that one weighs the effectiveness of various combinations between most of the known ADs and some second-generation antipsychotic (SGA) in the treatment of depression that occurs at different stages of schizophrenia. In previous studies, the use of vortioxetine as an adjunct to an antipsychotic yielded a reduction in negative symptoms, a clinically significant improvement in cognitive functions that differed from its antidepressant effect, and good tolerability, which affects how committed to treatment a patient remains.
To study the changes that occur over time in the clinical manifestations of depression, negative and cognitive impairment, as well as the social adequacy of patients receiving a combination therapy with second-generation antipsychotics and vortioxetine, which were prescribed in real clinical practice at doses approved in the Russian Federation.
We performed a comparative analysis of the changes in depression symptoms and negative symptoms, cognitive impairment, as well as function of 78 patients with severe manifestations of depression at the stage of exacerbation reduction and subsequent remission of paranoid schizophrenia. Combination treatment with SGA and vortioxetine was used in 39 patients, and 39 patients who had similar clinical manifestations received just SGA. During the observation period, the mental disorder severity and depression symptom severity were assessed 3 times (before the start of treatment, after three months, and after six months) using the Clinical Global Impression (CGI) scale and Calgary Depression Scale for Schizophrenia (CDSS), respectively; patients were also assessed using the Negative Symptoms Assessment-5 (NSA-5) scale, Perceived Deficits Questionnaire-20 items (PDQ-20) scale, and Personal and Social Performance (PSP) scale.
According to the ANOVA results, by the end of the observation period, patients, regardless of their therapeutic group, showed a statistically significant decrease in the level of depression on the CDSS scale, the severity of negative symptoms on the NSA-5 scale, cognitive symptoms on the PDQ-20 scale, as well as an improvement in personality and society, judging by the increase in the total PSP scores. There were also significant differences between the compared main (SGA + vortioxetine) and control (SGA) groups in terms of the changes in the total score on the CDSS and PSP scales. An interesting aspect of the changes in the clinical scores was a noticeable improvement in the SGA + vortioxetine group after 3 months of treatment, in the absence of a similar improvement in the control group, and the achievement of approximately the same scores in both groups after 6 months. In particular, there were significant differences between the SGA + vortioxetine and SGA groups in terms of the mean CDSS ( 0.001), NSA-5 (=0.003), PDQ-20 ( 0.001), and PSP (=0.004) scores after 3 months. Analysis of the time before early withdrawal from the study showed that significantly more patients in the SGA + vortioxetine group completed the study program (=27, 69.23%) compared with the SGA group (=13, 33.33%) ( =14.618, df=1, 0.001, log-rank test. The mean survival time in the SGA group was significantly ( 0.001) less and amounted to 101.436 days (95% CI: 81.518121.354), and in the SGA + vortioxetine group it amounted to 161.744 days (147.981175.506). The relative risk of full study completion in the vortioxetine + SGA group compared with that in SGA was 3.618 (1.8716.994).
The addition of vortioxetine to the SGA therapy accelerates the reduction of the depression symptoms that occur at the stage of psychosis regression and early remission, contributes to the accelerated reduction in negative symptoms, positively affects the subjective assessment of cognitive impairment severity, and has a significant positive effect on the level of psychosocial functioning.
精神分裂症患者的抑郁会通过增加自杀风险、使疾病临床表现复杂化以及降低社会功能质量来恶化疾病进程;其治疗困难,因为单一疗法,即使使用现代抗精神病药物,也并非总能成功。虽然加用抗抑郁药(ADs)可提高获得更好疗效的可能性,但在许多情况下这种增效疗法的有效性尚未得到证实。因此,权衡大多数已知抗抑郁药与某些第二代抗精神病药(SGA)的各种联合用药在治疗精神分裂症不同阶段出现的抑郁方面的有效性仍然很重要。在先前的研究中,使用伏硫西汀作为抗精神病药的辅助药物可减轻阴性症状,在认知功能方面产生与抗抑郁作用不同的具有临床意义的改善,并且耐受性良好,这会影响患者对治疗的依从性。
研究在俄罗斯联邦批准的剂量下,接受第二代抗精神病药与伏硫西汀联合治疗的患者,其抑郁、阴性和认知损害的临床表现以及社会适应能力随时间发生的变化。
我们对78例处于偏执型精神分裂症病情缓解期和后续缓解阶段且有严重抑郁表现的患者进行了对比分析,比较其抑郁症状、阴性症状、认知损害以及功能的变化。39例患者采用SGA与伏硫西汀联合治疗,39例有相似临床表现的患者仅接受SGA治疗。在观察期内,分别使用临床总体印象量表(CGI)和精神分裂症卡尔加里抑郁量表(CDSS)在治疗开始前、治疗三个月后和治疗六个月后三次评估精神障碍严重程度和抑郁症状严重程度;还使用阴性症状评估量表 - 5(NSA - 5)、感知缺陷问卷 - 20项(PDQ - 20)量表和个人与社会功能量表(PSP)对患者进行评估。
根据方差分析结果,到观察期末,无论治疗组如何,患者在CDSS量表上的抑郁水平、NSA - 5量表上的阴性症状严重程度、PDQ - 20量表上的认知症状均有统计学意义的下降,并且从PSP总分增加来看,人格和社会功能有所改善。在CDSS和PSP量表总分变化方面,比较的主要治疗组(SGA + 伏硫西汀)和对照组(SGA)之间也存在显著差异。临床评分变化的一个有趣方面是,治疗三个月后SGA + 伏硫西汀组有明显改善,而对照组没有类似改善,六个月后两组得分大致相同。特别是,治疗三个月后,SGA + 伏硫西汀组与SGA组在平均CDSS(P = 0.001)、NSA - 5(P = 0.003)、PDQ - 20(P = 0.001)和PSP(P = 0.004)得分方面存在显著差异。对提前退出研究前的时间进行分析表明,与SGA组(n = 13,33.33%)相比,SGA + 伏硫西汀组完成研究方案的患者明显更多(n = 27,69.23%)(χ² = 14.618,df = 1,P = 0.001,对数秩检验)。SGA组的平均生存时间显著更短(P = 0.001),为101.436天(95%置信区间:81.518 - 121.354),而SGA + 伏硫西汀组为161.744天(147.981 - 175.506)。与SGA组相比,伏硫西汀 + SGA组完成整个研究的相对风险为3.618(1.871 - 6.994)。
在SGA治疗中加用伏硫西汀可加速精神病消退期和早期缓解期出现的抑郁症状的减轻,有助于加速阴性症状的减轻,对认知损害严重程度的主观评估有积极影响,并且对心理社会功能水平有显著的积极作用。