Powell M A
Soc Sci Med. 1986;23(10):1093-103. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(86)90268-6.
This paper is part of a larger piece of research which examines the spatial relationship between need for and provision of primary health care in London. The research reported here is concerned with empirically testing the 'inverse care law' at the DHA level. One concept that may be used to guide this analysis is 'territorial justice'. Several conceptual problems associated with the use of territorial justice are outlined. These include inadequate conceptualisation of the form of social justice assumed, of the problem of deriving need indices and of the nature of resources. A final problem is concerned with the spatial scale of the analysis. The concept of territorial justice is made operational so as to identify relatively under and overprovided DHAs. The result is that the often held assumption of a simple dichotomy of relatively underprovided inner DHAs and overprovided outer DHAs is shown not to be tenable. However, this research concentrates on the quantity of care, and does not focus on the important aspect of its quality. This preliminary analysis reveals the need for further research on this important topic.
本文是一项更大规模研究的一部分,该研究考察了伦敦初级卫生保健的需求与供给之间的空间关系。此处报告的研究关注于在区卫生局(DHA)层面实证检验“逆医疗法则”。一个可用于指导该分析的概念是“地域公平”。概述了与使用地域公平相关的几个概念性问题。这些问题包括对所假定的社会公平形式、推导需求指数的问题以及资源性质的概念化不足。最后一个问题涉及分析的空间尺度。地域公平概念得以实施,以便识别供给相对不足和供给过剩的区卫生局。结果表明,通常认为相对供给不足的内城区区卫生局和供给过剩的外城区区卫生局简单二分的假设是站不住脚的。然而,这项研究集中在医疗服务的数量上,并未关注其质量这一重要方面。这一初步分析表明有必要对这一重要主题进行进一步研究。