Malina R M, Brown K H, Zavaleta A N
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1987 Jan;72(1):89-94. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330720111.
Stature, sitting height, estimated leg (subischial) length and the sitting height/stature ratio are compared in Mexican American, American White and American Black boys 9 through 14 years of age and girls 12 through 17 years of age. Mexican American youth are shorter in stature and have absolutely shorter lower extremities. The sitting height of Mexican American youth is similar to that of Black youth and shorter than that of White youth. The sitting height/stature ratio is virtually identical in Mexican American and White youth, indicating similar proportions of lower extremities to stature. In contrast, Black youth have absolutely and relatively longer lower extremities than Mexican American and White youth. These results would thus seem to suggest that reference data for the body mass index (BMI) based on American White youth can be used with Mexican American youth, while race-specific values may be necessary for American Black youth. However, ethnic variation in physique, perhaps frame size, may be a factor which should be more systematically considered in evaluating the utility of the body mass index.
对9至14岁的墨西哥裔美国男孩、美国白人男孩和美国黑人男孩,以及12至17岁的墨西哥裔美国女孩、美国白人女孩和美国黑人女孩的身高、坐高、估计腿长(坐骨下长度)和坐高/身高比进行了比较。墨西哥裔美国青少年身高较矮,下肢绝对长度较短。墨西哥裔美国青少年的坐高与黑人青少年相似,比白人青少年短。墨西哥裔美国青少年和白人青少年的坐高/身高比几乎相同,表明下肢与身高的比例相似。相比之下,黑人青少年的下肢绝对长度和相对长度都比墨西哥裔美国青少年和白人青少年长。因此,这些结果似乎表明,基于美国白人青少年的体重指数(BMI)参考数据可用于墨西哥裔美国青少年,而美国黑人青少年可能需要特定种族的值。然而,体质的种族差异,可能是体格大小,在评估体重指数的效用时可能是一个需要更系统地考虑的因素。