Shimshi-Barash Maya, Orlin Ido, Jacob Tali, Kushnir Gali, Rawashdeh Lara, Rothem Nachmias Etay, Meiri Noam, Pillar Giora
Department of Pediatrics and Pediatric Sleep Medicine, Carmel Medical Center, Technion Faculty of Medicine, 7 Michasl St., 3436212, Haifa, Israel.
Sci Rep. 2024 Jan 29;14(1):2357. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-52943-2.
Intervention by medical clowns was proven to have a positive effect in reducing stress and anxiety, increasing cooperation and improving the child's experience prior to a medical procedure and during the various stages of hospitalization. Sleep has long been known to be essential for recovery from injury and sickness, improving immune functions, and there is an emerging understanding of the restorative role quality sleep has on health and diseases. Hospitalized children are more exposed to sleep disorders and sleep deprivation due to the hospitalized environment, anxiety, and illness. Different behavioral interventions to promote sleep were previously studied in hospitalized children, some showing potential benefits. In this study, we sought to examine the ability of medical clowns to positively impact the child's sleep during hospitalization. The study is an observational matching (case-control) interventional study which took place at the department of pediatrics in Carmel Medical Center. Forty-two hospitalized children ages 2-17 were included in two equal groups of intervention or control. Children in the control group were recruited based on a method of matching the chief complaint plus the medical diagnosis and age of the children in the intervention group in a 1:1 matching. The children's sleep parameters were objectively evaluated for two consecutive nights using an Actigraph device and subjectively by parent's questionnaire. Additional factors such as hospital length of stay and demographics were also monitored. The study group had an encounter with a medical clown (15-30 min) before bedtime on either the first or the second night, and the control group was not exposed to a medical clown at all. We then compared the data from both groups using unpaired t-tests. Hospitalized children exposed to a medical clown prior to bedtime (n = 21) and children not exposed to a medical clown (n = 21) were comparable in age and clinical characteristics. The study group had a significantly delayed wake-up time compared to the control group (06:59 ± 46 min vs. 07:26 ± 42 min, p < 0.05) (mean difference of 27 min). Night's duration (from bedtime to wake-up) was significantly longer in the study versus the control group (570 ± 76 vs. 500 ± 66.1 min, p < 0.05), a total mean increase of 70 min, and sleep efficiency were significantly increased (92.3 ± 4.6% vs. 87.9 ± 8.7%, p < 0.05). Within the clown group, when comparing nights with and without exposure to a medical clown, total sleep time was prolonged by a mean of 54 min on the night of the intervention (518 ± 74 min vs. 464 ± 59 min, p < 0.01), and the total wake time during the night were reduced (52 ± 27 min vs. 77 ± 61 min, P < 0.05), mean difference of 25 min), mainly by reduction of wake period after sleep onset (WASO) (42 ± 25 min vs. 66 ± 58 min, p < 0.05), mean difference of 24 min). Regarding general medical outcomes, hospital stay was significantly shorter in the clown group vs. control (104 ± 42 h vs. 128 ± 42 h, p < 0.05), a mean reduction of 23 h-nearly an entire day. An encounter with a medical clown before bedtime in hospitalized children positively affects sleep parameters, which may be of great importance for healing in general. The clown intervention was also shown to shorten the hospital stay. Larger scale studies are warranted to establish these findings.
事实证明,医疗小丑的干预对于减轻压力和焦虑、增强合作以及改善孩子在医疗程序前和住院各个阶段的体验具有积极作用。长期以来,人们都知道睡眠对于从伤病中恢复、改善免疫功能至关重要,并且对于优质睡眠在健康和疾病方面的恢复作用也有了新的认识。住院儿童由于住院环境、焦虑和疾病等因素,更容易出现睡眠障碍和睡眠不足。此前对住院儿童进行了不同的促进睡眠的行为干预研究,其中一些显示出了潜在益处。在本研究中,我们试图考察医疗小丑对住院儿童睡眠产生积极影响的能力。该研究是一项在卡梅尔医疗中心儿科进行的观察性匹配(病例对照)干预研究。42名年龄在2至17岁的住院儿童被分为两组,每组人数相等,分别为干预组和对照组。对照组儿童是根据与干预组儿童的主要诉求、医学诊断和年龄进行1:1匹配的方法招募的。使用活动记录仪连续两晚客观评估儿童的睡眠参数,并通过家长问卷进行主观评估。还监测了住院时间和人口统计学等其他因素。研究组在第一晚或第二晚睡前与医疗小丑接触(15至30分钟),而对照组则完全没有接触医疗小丑。然后我们使用非配对t检验比较两组的数据。睡前接触医疗小丑的住院儿童(n = 21)和未接触医疗小丑的儿童(n = 21)在年龄和临床特征方面具有可比性。与对照组相比,研究组的起床时间明显延迟(06:59 ± 46分钟对07:26 ± 42分钟,p < 0.05)(平均差异为27分钟)。研究组的夜间时长(从就寝到起床)明显长于对照组(570 ± 76对500 ± 66.1分钟,p < 0.05),总共平均增加了70分钟,睡眠效率也显著提高(92.3 ± 4.6%对87.9 ± 8.7%,p < 0.05)。在小丑组内,比较接触医疗小丑的夜晚和未接触医疗小丑的夜晚,干预当晚的总睡眠时间平均延长了54分钟(518 ± 74分钟对464 ± 59分钟,p < 0.01),夜间总清醒时间减少(52 ± 27分钟对77 ± 61分钟,P < 0.05),平均差异为25分钟),主要是通过减少睡眠开始后的清醒期(WASO)(42 ± 25分钟对66 ± 58分钟,p < 0.05),平均差异为24分钟)。关于一般医疗结果,小丑组的住院时间明显短于对照组(104 ± 42小时对128 ± 42小时,p < 0.05),平均减少了23小时——几乎一整天。住院儿童睡前与医疗小丑接触对睡眠参数有积极影响,这总体上可能对康复非常重要。小丑干预还显示出缩短了住院时间。有必要进行更大规模的研究来证实这些发现。