Thorsen M M, Khanuja K, Mahoney R C, Al-Kouatly H B, Russo M L
Alpert Medical School of Brown University / Women & Infants Hospital of Rhode Island, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Prenat Diagn. 2024 Mar;44(3):297-303. doi: 10.1002/pd.6524. Epub 2024 Jan 31.
Comprehensive counseling on prenatal genetic screening and diagnostic testing is challenging for clinicians. We sought to identify baseline clinician knowledge of prenatal genetic screening and diagnostic testing and needs to promote counseling aligned with ACOG recommendations.
We performed an anonymous, cross-sectional survey of clinicians at two unaffiliated, tertiary academic institutions to assess the knowledge of, confidence in, and time spent counseling on prenatal genetic screening and diagnostic testing. Stata (Version 17, College Station, TX) was used to perform descriptive statistics. Deductive and inductive coding was used to analyze responses regarding ideal education resources.
The survey response rate was 78% (100/129). Only 36% of respondents correctly answered knowledge questions about prenatal genetic screening and diagnostic testing. A majority, 59% (16/39), of those confident or extremely confident in counseling were unable to answer all questions accurately. Respondents reported a median of 5.6 min (95% CI 4.9-6.4 min) spent counseling. Thematic analysis of free responses revealed desire for visual tools that discuss financial costs and patient values.
Surveyed clinicians demonstrated deficiencies in knowledge about prenatal genetic counseling. To provide better and more comprehensive care, we noted a desire for the development of formalized resources for clinician and patient education.
对临床医生而言,开展关于产前基因筛查和诊断检测的全面咨询具有挑战性。我们试图确定临床医生对产前基因筛查和诊断检测的基线知识,以及促进符合美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)建议的咨询服务的需求。
我们对两所非附属的三级学术机构的临床医生进行了一项匿名横断面调查,以评估他们对产前基因筛查和诊断检测的知识、信心以及咨询所花费的时间。使用Stata(版本17,德克萨斯州大学城)进行描述性统计。采用演绎和归纳编码来分析关于理想教育资源的回答。
调查回复率为78%(100/129)。只有36%的受访者正确回答了关于产前基因筛查和诊断检测的知识问题。在那些对咨询有信心或极其有信心的人中,有59%(16/39)无法准确回答所有问题。受访者报告咨询花费的中位数为5.6分钟(95%置信区间4.9 - 6.4分钟)。对自由回答的主题分析显示,他们希望有讨论财务成本和患者价值观的视觉工具。
接受调查的临床医生在产前基因咨询知识方面存在不足。为了提供更好、更全面的护理,我们注意到需要为临床医生和患者教育开发正式的资源。