Kękuś Magdalena, Szpitalak Malwina, Polczyk Romuald, Barzykowski Krystian
Faculty of Psychology in Kraków, SWPS University, Kraków, Poland.
Institute of Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland.
Front Psychol. 2024 Jan 17;14:1239139. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1239139. eCollection 2023.
The memory conformity effect occurs when people witness a given incident and then talk to each other about it, and the statement of one person affects the memory account of another person with respect to that incident. The main objectives of this experiment were (1) to examine the effectiveness of a modified version of the MORI-v technique in inducing the memory conformity effect and (2) to investigate how the manner in which participants discuss the observed event influences the magnitude of this effect. In general, the modified online MORI-v technique consists of the following main elements: (1) , that is, two versions of a short film which are identical except for certain critical details; for example, in one version, a thief puts on a red cap, but in the other version it is black; (2) the , that is, a discussion about the original material which leads to mutual misinformation; and (3) an that checks the effect of the discussion on the memory account of the original material.
A total of 72 participants (36 pairs) aged 18-54 took part in the research. Participants were tested using the online MORI-v technique: They were familiarized with the original material on their computers at home, and then they talked about it via a video communication app and completed an individual recognition test on their computers. Importantly, the discussions were recorded and analyzed in detail after the experimental session.
Using the online MORI-v technique, the effect of memory conformity was demonstrated, that is, in the individual recognition test, the proportion of correct answers to questions about discussed details (related to misinformation) was lower than the proportion of correct answers to questions about non-discussed details. It was also demonstrated that if one participant introduced misinformation during the discussion about a particular item and the other did not question it, the latter's answer to that item during the individual recognition test was most often incorrect. However, if one participant introduced misinformation during the discussion about an item and the other questioned it, the latter's answer about that item during the individual recognition test was most often correct.
当人们目睹某一特定事件,然后相互谈论此事时,就会出现记忆一致性效应,即一个人的陈述会影响另一个人对该事件的记忆描述。本实验的主要目的是:(1)检验改良版的MORI-v技术在诱发记忆一致性效应方面的有效性;(2)研究参与者讨论所观察事件的方式如何影响这一效应的程度。一般来说,改良版的在线MORI-v技术由以下主要元素组成:(1) ,即一部短片的两个版本,除了某些关键细节外完全相同;例如,在一个版本中,一个小偷戴了一顶红色帽子,但在另一个版本中是黑色的;(2) ,即关于原始材料的讨论,会导致相互间的错误信息;(3) ,用于检查讨论对原始材料记忆描述的影响。
共有72名年龄在18至54岁之间的参与者(36对)参与了这项研究。参与者使用在线MORI-v技术进行测试:他们在家中通过电脑熟悉原始材料,然后通过视频通信应用程序进行讨论,并在电脑上完成个人识别测试。重要的是,实验结束后对讨论进行了详细记录和分析。
使用在线MORI-v技术,证明了记忆一致性效应,即在个人识别测试中,关于讨论细节(与错误信息相关)问题的正确答案比例低于关于未讨论细节问题的正确答案比例。还证明,如果一名参与者在关于某个特定项目的讨论中引入了错误信息,而另一名参与者没有提出质疑,那么后者在个人识别测试中对该项目的回答最常是错误的。然而,如果一名参与者在关于某个项目的讨论中引入了错误信息,而另一名参与者提出了质疑,那么后者在个人识别测试中关于该项目的回答最常是正确的。