Pillai Jayasankar P, Dodia Vaishali, Monpara Pooja, Shah Khushali, Odedra Sima
Department of Oral Pathology, Govt. Dental College and Hospital, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
Associate Dentist, Shri Ramakrishna Ashrama Medical Center, Rajkot, Gujarat, India.
J Oral Maxillofac Pathol. 2023 Oct-Dec;27(4):748-753. doi: 10.4103/jomfp.jomfp_292_23. Epub 2023 Dec 20.
Age estimation is one of the prime requisites in forensic human identification cases and the criminal justice system. There are several age estimation methods using dental parameters. A method proposed by Mincer . which uses the mineralization stages of third molars based on Demirjian's developmental stages is less tested in the Indian population.
The present study aimed to assess the developmental status of the third molars and to apply and validate Mincer .'s method on the Western India population.
A total of 306 orthopantomograms (OPGs) from 128 males and 178 females with a mean age of 16.89 years ± 3.68 were analysed. Demirjian's A-H staging was applied to record the developmental stages of 1100 third molars. Mincer .'s mean age of attainment was applied based on the American Whites (Caucasian) population for males and females separately using stages of #18 and #38.
There was a slight overestimation of the chronological age (CA) in both #18 and #38. The females showed more accurate estimated age (EA) than males.
Mincer .'s method is a convenient age estimation method using the third molar's developmental stage. The mean age of attainment mentioned in the original Mincer .'s study can be used in the Western Indian population, with a residual value ranging from 0.21 to 0.25 years.
年龄估计是法医人体识别案件和刑事司法系统中的主要要求之一。有几种使用牙齿参数的年龄估计方法。Mincer提出的一种方法,该方法基于Demirjian的发育阶段使用第三磨牙的矿化阶段,在印度人群中较少得到验证。
本研究旨在评估第三磨牙的发育状况,并在印度西部人群中应用和验证Mincer的方法。
共分析了128名男性和178名女性的306张口腔全景片(OPG),平均年龄为16.89岁±3.68岁。应用Demirjian的A-H分期记录1100颗第三磨牙的发育阶段。根据美国白人(高加索人)人群,分别对男性和女性使用#18和#38阶段应用Mincer的平均萌出年龄。
#18和#38的实足年龄(CA)均略有高估。女性的估计年龄(EA)比男性更准确。
Mincer的方法是一种利用第三磨牙发育阶段的便捷年龄估计方法。原始Mincer研究中提到的平均萌出年龄可用于印度西部人群,残差值在0.21至0.25岁之间。