School of Health Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47906, United States of America; Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA 02115, United States of America.
School of Health Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47906, United States of America.
Sci Total Environ. 2024 Mar 25;918:170601. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.170601. Epub 2024 Feb 1.
Metals continue to impose health issues among world populations. A non-invasive alternative biomarker for assessment of metals and other elements has been explored in other studies using toenail samples. Some benefits of using toenails as biomarkers over blood samples include cost efficiency, ease of collection, and a longer biological half-life within samples. The objective of this study was to employ desktop XRF for the purpose of measuring metal concentrations in human nail samples, thus conducting a non-destructive assessment. These benefits paired with comparable accuracy in exposure detection could prove toenail samples to be a preferred biomarker for many studies. Current elemental quantification techniques in toenail samples could be improved. The standard practice for measuring metal exposure in toenails, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), has a counterpart in x-ray fluorescence. While maintaining similar quantification capabilities, x-ray fluorescence could provide decreased cost, preservation of samples, and ease of operation. Portable XRF machines have been tested for measuring toenail samples, but they have drastically increased detection limits in comparison to ICP-MS. New benchtop XRF systems should give comparable detection limits to ICP-MS. This study compares the benchtop XRF measurements of lead (Pb), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), and Selenium (Se) levels to that of ICP-MS measurements of toenail samples and calculates estimated detection limits for 23 other elements. We found strong correlations for the toenail lead (R = 0.92), copper (R = 0.95), selenium (R = 0.60), and iron (R = 0.77) comparison between desktop XRF and ICP-MS measurements. Median minimum detection limits over the 23 elements were found to be 0.2 μg/g using a 7.5-min measurement. Benchtop XRF provides a lower detection limit than previously studied portable XRF machines, which gives it the capability of accurately detecting almost any desired element in nail samples. Benchtop XRF provides a non-destructive alternative to ICP-MS in surveillance of nail samples.
金属继续对世界人口的健康造成影响。其他研究已经探索了使用趾甲样本作为替代生物标志物来评估金属和其他元素的非侵入性方法。与血液样本相比,使用趾甲作为生物标志物的一些好处包括成本效益、易于采集以及样本中更长的生物半衰期。本研究的目的是使用台式 XRF 测量人指甲样本中的金属浓度,从而进行非破坏性评估。这些优势与在暴露检测方面相当的准确性相结合,可能证明趾甲样本是许多研究的首选生物标志物。目前在趾甲样本中进行元素定量的技术可以得到改进。测量趾甲中金属暴露的标准做法是电感耦合等离子体质谱法 (ICP-MS),X 射线荧光法与之相对应。虽然保持类似的定量能力,X 射线荧光法可以降低成本、保存样本并简化操作。便携式 XRF 机器已被测试用于测量趾甲样本,但与 ICP-MS 相比,它们的检测限大大增加。新型台式 XRF 系统应具有与 ICP-MS 相当的检测限。本研究将台式 XRF 对铅 (Pb)、铜 (Cu)、铁 (Fe) 和硒 (Se) 水平的测量结果与 ICP-MS 对趾甲样本的测量结果进行了比较,并计算了 23 种其他元素的估计检测限。我们发现台式 XRF 与 ICP-MS 测量结果之间的趾甲铅 (R = 0.92)、铜 (R = 0.95)、硒 (R = 0.60) 和铁 (R = 0.77) 比较具有很强的相关性。在 23 种元素中,使用 7.5 分钟的测量,发现中位数最小检测限为 0.2μg/g。台式 XRF 提供的检测限低于之前研究的便携式 XRF 机器,这使其具有在指甲样本中准确检测几乎任何所需元素的能力。台式 XRF 为 ICP-MS 监测指甲样本提供了一种非破坏性的替代方法。