School of Transportation, Southeast University, China.
School of Transportation, Southeast University, China.
Accid Anal Prev. 2024 Apr;198:107486. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2024.107486. Epub 2024 Feb 3.
Extensive research has examined the potential benefits of Automated Vehicles (AVs) for increasing traffic capacity and improving safety. However, previous studies on AV longitudinal control have focused primarily on control stability and instability or tradeoffs between safety and stability, neglecting the importance of vehicle damping characteristics. This study aims to demonstrate the significance of explicitly considering safety in addition to stability in AV longitudinal control through damping behavior analysis. Specifically, it proposes a safety-oriented AV longitudinal control and provides recommendations on the control parameters. For the proposed AV control, an Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) model is integrated with damping behavior analysis to model AV safety under continuous traffic perturbations. Numerical simulations are conducted to quantify the relationship between mobility and safety for AVs considering both damping behavior and control stability. Different ACC control parameters are evaluated in terms of damping and stability properties, and their safety impacts are assessed based on various surrogate safety measures such as Deceleration Rate to Avoid Crash (DRAC), Crash Potential Index (CPI) and Time-Integrated Time-to-collision (TIT). The results indicate that an underdamped state (ACC damping ratio < 1) is less safe than the critically damped state (ACC damping ratio = 1) and the overdamped state (ACC damping ratio > 1). Furthermore, given the same AV car-following time lag, ACC with a damping ratio between 1 and 1.2 provides better safety performance. Increasing the AV car-following time lag can improve both safety and stability when the remaining ACC control parameters are kept the same. In this case, the optimal safety-oriented ACC regions also increase. The findings of this study provide important insights into designing safe and stable AV longitudinal control algorithms.
大量研究已经考察了自动驾驶汽车 (AV) 在提高交通容量和提高安全性方面的潜在优势。然而,之前关于 AV 纵向控制的研究主要集中在控制稳定性和不稳定性,或者在安全性和稳定性之间进行权衡,而忽略了车辆阻尼特性的重要性。本研究旨在通过阻尼行为分析证明在 AV 纵向控制中除了稳定性之外还明确考虑安全性的重要性。具体来说,它提出了一种面向安全性的 AV 纵向控制,并提供了关于控制参数的建议。对于所提出的 AV 控制,自适应巡航控制 (ACC) 模型与阻尼行为分析相结合,以在连续交通干扰下对 AV 安全进行建模。进行数值模拟以量化考虑阻尼和控制稳定性的情况下 AV 的移动性和安全性之间的关系。根据不同的 ACC 控制参数,评估了阻尼和稳定性特性,并根据各种替代安全措施(例如减速避免碰撞率 (DRAC)、碰撞潜力指数 (CPI) 和碰撞时间积分 (TIT))评估了它们的安全影响。结果表明,欠阻尼状态(ACC 阻尼比 < 1)不如临界阻尼状态(ACC 阻尼比 = 1)和过阻尼状态(ACC 阻尼比 > 1)安全。此外,在相同的 AV 跟车时滞下,阻尼比在 1 到 1.2 之间的 ACC 提供更好的安全性能。当保持相同的剩余 ACC 控制参数时,增加 AV 跟车时滞可以提高安全性和稳定性。在这种情况下,最佳的面向安全的 ACC 区域也会增加。本研究的结果为设计安全稳定的 AV 纵向控制算法提供了重要的见解。