Lim-Reinders Stephanie, Ward Michelle G K, Malic Claudia, Keely Kathryn, Kang Kristopher, Jain Nita, Zwicker Kelley
Department of Paediatrics, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada.
Division of Plastic Surgery, Department of Paediatric Surgery, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada.
Paediatr Child Health. 2023 Sep 28;29(1):23-28. doi: 10.1093/pch/pxad064. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic there has been a documented decline in reports to child protective services, despite an increased incidence of child maltreatment. This is concerning for increasing missed cases. This study aims to examine if and how Canadian paediatricians are identifying maltreatment in virtual medical appointments.
A survey was sent through the Canadian Paediatric Surveillance Program (CPSP) to 2770 practicing general and subspecialty paediatricians. Data was collected November 2021 to January 2022.
With a 34% (928/2770) response rate, 704 surveys were eligible for analysis. At least one case of child maltreatment was reported by 11% (78/700) of respondents following a virtual appointment. The number of cases reported was associated with years in medical practice (P = 0.026) but not with the volume (P = 0.735) or prior experience (P = 0.127) with virtual care, or perceived difficulty in identifying cases virtually (Cramer's V = 0.096). The most common factors triggering concern were the presence of social stressors, or a clear disclosure. The virtual physical exam was not contributory. Nearly one quarter (24%, 34/143) required a subsequent in-person appointment prior to reporting the case and 32% (207/648) reported concerns that a case had been identified late, or missed, following a virtual appointment. Some commented that clear harm resulted.
Many barriers to detecting child maltreatment were identified by paediatricians who used virtual care. This survey reveals that virtual care may be an important factor in missed cases of child maltreatment and may present challenges to timely identification.
在整个新冠疫情大流行期间,尽管儿童虐待事件的发生率有所上升,但向儿童保护服务机构报告的案件数量却有记录显示在下降。这令人担忧,因为漏报案件可能会增多。本研究旨在调查加拿大儿科医生在虚拟医疗预约中是否以及如何识别虐待行为。
通过加拿大儿科监测项目(CPSP)向2770名执业普通儿科和专科儿科医生发送了一份调查问卷。数据收集时间为2021年11月至2022年1月。
回复率为34%(928/2770),704份调查问卷符合分析条件。11%(78/700)的受访者在虚拟预约后报告了至少一例儿童虐待案件。报告的案件数量与医疗实践年限有关(P = 0.026),但与虚拟护理的数量(P = 0.735)、先前经验(P = 0.127)或在虚拟环境中识别案件的感知难度无关(克莱姆系数V = 0.096)。引发关注的最常见因素是存在社会压力源或明确的披露。虚拟体格检查并无帮助。近四分之一(24%,34/143)的人在报告案件之前需要随后进行面对面预约,32%(207/648)的人报告担心在虚拟预约后案件被发现得太晚或被漏报。一些人评论说造成了明显的伤害。
使用虚拟护理的儿科医生发现了许多在检测儿童虐待方面存在的障碍。这项调查表明,虚拟护理可能是儿童虐待漏报案件中的一个重要因素,并且可能给及时识别带来挑战。