Kjeld Simone G, Homberg Teresa, Andersen Susan
National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Centre for Childhood Health, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Scand J Public Health. 2025 Feb;53(1):41-51. doi: 10.1177/14034948241227305. Epub 2024 Feb 11.
Smoking and poor mental health in youth represent important public health priorities. This study aimed to (i) compare tobacco-related behaviors and mental health in two educational settings with high smoking rates: vocational education and training (VET) schools and preparatory basic education (PBE) schools, and (ii) examine associations between smoking at school start and mental health 5 months later.
Data were obtained from baseline ( = 1843) and follow-up ( = 1039) assessments conducted as part of a school-based trial in two rounds (baseline in August 2018 and August 2019). Students' characteristics were presented by adjusted prevalences. Logistic regression analyses assessed associations between smoking and measures of mental health: school-related well-being, overall loneliness, and stress.
More PBE students than VET students reported daily smoking (40% vs. 27%), nicotine dependence, perceived benefits of smoking (e.g., stress reduction: 41% vs. 33%), low smoking-related self-efficacy (e.g., ability to resist smoking if offered by a friend: 20% vs. 32%), school-related loneliness, and low school connectedness (25% vs. 11%). Daily smokers at VET and PBE schools had lower odds of school-related loneliness (AOR = 0.51, 95% CI: 0.35-0.74) and higher odds of stress (AOR = 2.75, 95% CI: 2.00-3.80). Smoking was associated with better classmate relations in VET schools but not in PBE schools.
Our study suggested that students in PBE schools constitute a more vulnerable group in terms of smoking and mental health compared with students in VET schools. Smoking seemed to prevent loneliness in school but was associated with heightened stress levels.
青少年吸烟和心理健康状况不佳是重要的公共卫生优先事项。本研究旨在:(i)比较职业教育培训(VET)学校和预备基础教育(PBE)学校这两个吸烟率较高的教育环境中的烟草相关行为和心理健康状况;(ii)研究入学时吸烟与5个月后的心理健康之间的关联。
数据来自两轮以学校为基础的试验的基线(n = 1843)和随访(n = 1039)评估(2018年8月和2019年8月为基线)。学生特征以调整后的患病率呈现。逻辑回归分析评估吸烟与心理健康指标之间的关联:与学校相关的幸福感、总体孤独感和压力。
报告每日吸烟的PBE学生比VET学生更多(40%对27%),存在尼古丁依赖,认为吸烟有益(例如减轻压力:41%对33%),吸烟相关的自我效能感低(例如如果朋友提供能抵抗吸烟的能力:20%对32%),与学校相关的孤独感以及与学校的联系薄弱(25%对11%)。VET学校和PBE学校的每日吸烟者与学校相关的孤独感几率较低(优势比[AOR]=0.51,95%置信区间[CI]:0.35 - 0.74),压力几率较高(AOR = 2.75,95% CI:2.00 - 3.80)。在VET学校吸烟与较好的同学关系相关,但在PBE学校则不然。
我们的研究表明,与VET学校的学生相比,PBE学校的学生在吸烟和心理健康方面构成更脆弱的群体。吸烟似乎能预防学校中的孤独感,但与压力水平升高有关。