National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Studiestræde 6, Kobenhavn 1455, Denmark.
Health Promot Int. 2023 Apr 1;38(2). doi: 10.1093/heapro/daad030.
Youth is a crucial period for smoking preventive interventions. School-based interventions targeting the policy level and the sociocultural processes of smoking show promising effects in reducing smoking uptake and prevalence. This study presents findings from the qualitative process evaluation of a smoking preventive intervention, Focus, in the vocational school (VET) setting. Specifically, the study focused on contextual factors affecting the implementation of smoke-free school hours (SFSH). Participant observations and focus groups were conducted in four VETs during the implementation period October-December 2018. The data encompass participant observation field notes (n = 21 school days), student focus groups (n = 8) (aged 16-20), teacher focus groups (n = 5) and semi-structured individual interviews with VET leaders (n = 3). The study found that SFSH was not clearly communicated to students due to the educational structure and chaotic rhythm of the school days, ambivalent attitudes among teachers toward enforcement of smoking rules and lack of clear managerial support. The interplay of these factors counteracted the implementation of SFSH in the VET context. The presented contextual factors are important when interpreting the effectiveness of the Focus intervention and for informing future preventive efforts aiming to reduce smoking among youth in high risk of smoking cigarettes.
青年时期是进行吸烟预防干预的关键时期。以政策层面和吸烟的社会文化进程为目标的学校为基础的干预措施,在减少吸烟率和吸烟流行率方面显示出了有前景的效果。本研究展示了一项在职业学校(VET)环境中进行的吸烟预防干预措施 Focus 的定性过程评估的结果。具体来说,该研究侧重于影响无烟学校时间(SFSH)实施的背景因素。在 2018 年 10 月至 12 月的实施期间,在四所 VET 中进行了参与者观察和焦点小组讨论。数据包括参与者观察的实地记录(n = 21 个上学日)、学生焦点小组(n = 8)(年龄在 16-20 岁之间)、教师焦点小组(n = 5)和 VET 领导的半结构化个人访谈(n = 3)。研究发现,由于教育结构和学校日子的混乱节奏,SFSH 并没有向学生清楚地传达,教师对执行吸烟规则的态度模棱两可,缺乏明确的管理支持。这些因素的相互作用抵消了 SFSH 在 VET 环境中的实施。在解释 Focus 干预措施的有效性和为未来旨在减少有吸烟风险的青年吸烟的预防工作提供信息时,呈现的背景因素非常重要。