Rosar W H
Perception. 1985;14(4):403-25. doi: 10.1068/p140403.
The geometrical incongruence between patterns in visual space and structures and patterns of activity in the visual cortex, long known to investigators, serves as a criterion for evaluating physical theories of visual space. The problem of determining the geometry of the visual world (visual geometry) is compared with that of determining the geometry of the physical world (physical geometry). Theories as to the possible physical locus of visual space, whether in the brain or elsewhere, are reviewed, analyzed, and criticized accordingly. It is concluded that on the basis of congruence alone it would be predicted that visual space is not to be found in the brain, even though it is seemingly linked to it causally, as experimental neurology and neurophysiology demonstrate. Alternative theories as to the nature of visual space are considered, but are also found to be inadequate in explaining visual space in terms acceptable to contemporary science.
视觉空间中的模式与视觉皮层中的结构及活动模式之间的几何不一致,早已为研究者们所知,它作为评估视觉空间物理理论的一个标准。确定视觉世界的几何形状(视觉几何学)的问题与确定物理世界的几何形状(物理几何学)的问题相比较。关于视觉空间可能的物理位置的理论,无论其位于大脑还是其他地方,都据此进行了综述、分析和批判。得出的结论是,仅基于一致性来预测,即使如实验神经学和神经生理学所证明的那样,视觉空间与大脑似乎存在因果联系,也无法在大脑中找到视觉空间。关于视觉空间本质的其他理论也被考虑过,但也发现它们在以当代科学可接受的方式解释视觉空间方面存在不足。