Holmes Corinne A, Cooney Sarah M, Dempsey Paula, Newell Fiona N
School of Psychology and Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, College Green, Dublin 2, Ireland.
School of Psychology and Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, College Green, Dublin 2, Ireland; School of Psychology, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2024 May;241:105870. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2024.105870. Epub 2024 Feb 13.
Geometrical knowledge is typically taught to children through a combination of vision and repetitive drawing (i.e. haptics), yet our understanding of how different spatial senses contribute to geometric perception during childhood is poor. Studies of line orientation suggest a dominant role of vision affecting the calibration of haptics during development; however, the associated multisensory interactions underpinning angle perception are unknown. Here we examined visual, haptic, and bimodal perception of angles across three age groups of children: 6 to 8 years, 8 to 10 years, and 10 to 12 years, with age categories also representing their class (grade) in primary school. All participants first learned an angular shape, presented dynamically, in one of three sensory tracing conditions: visual only, haptic only, or bimodal exploration. At test, which was visual only, participants selected a target angle from four possible alternatives with distractor angle sizes varying relative to the target angle size. We found a clear improvement in accuracy of angle perception with development for all learning modalities. Angle perception in the youngest group was equally poor (but above chance) for all modalities; however, for the two older child groups, visual learning was better than haptics. Haptic perception did not improve to the level of vision with age (even in a comparison adult group), and we found no specific benefit for bimodal learning over visual learning in any age group, including adults. Our results support a developmental increment in both spatial accuracy and precision in all modalities, which was greater in vision than in haptics, and are consistent with previous accounts of cross-sensory calibration in the perception of geometric forms.
几何知识通常通过视觉和反复绘图(即触觉)相结合的方式教授给儿童,但我们对童年时期不同空间感官如何影响几何感知的了解却很有限。对线方向的研究表明,在发育过程中,视觉在影响触觉校准方面起主导作用;然而,支撑角度感知的相关多感官交互作用尚不清楚。在这里,我们研究了三个年龄组儿童(6至8岁、8至10岁和10至12岁,年龄分组也代表他们在小学的年级)对角度的视觉、触觉和双模式感知。所有参与者首先在三种感官追踪条件之一中动态学习一个角形状:仅视觉、仅触觉或双模式探索。在仅视觉的测试中,参与者从四个可能的选项中选择一个目标角度,干扰角度大小相对于目标角度大小有所不同。我们发现,所有学习模式下,随着发育,角度感知的准确性都有明显提高。最年幼组的所有模式下角度感知都同样较差(但高于随机水平);然而,对于两个较大的儿童组,视觉学习优于触觉学习。触觉感知并没有随着年龄增长提高到视觉水平(即使在与之比较的成人组中也是如此),而且我们发现在任何年龄组(包括成人)中,双模式学习相对于视觉学习都没有特别的优势。我们的结果支持了所有模式下空间准确性和精度的发育性提高,视觉方面的提高大于触觉方面,并且与之前关于几何形状感知中跨感官校准的描述一致。