Vettini Amanda, Brennan Gearóid K, Mercer Stewart W, Jackson Caroline A
Centre for Population Health Sciences, Usher Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Faculty of Health Sciences & Sport, University of Stirling, Stirling, UK.
BJGP Open. 2024 Jul 29;8(2). doi: 10.3399/BJGPO.2023.0176. Print 2024 Jul.
Patients with severe mental illness (SMI) die 10-20 years earlier than the general population. They have a higher risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) yet may experience lower cardioprotective medication prescribing.
To understand the challenges experienced by GPs in prescribing cardioprotective medication to patients with SMI.
DESIGN & SETTING: A qualitative study with 15 GPs from 11 practices in two Scottish health boards, including practices servicing highly deprived areas (Deep End).
Semi-structured one-to-one interviews with fully qualified GPs with clinical experience of patients with SMI. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed thematically.
Participants aimed to routinely prescribe cardioprotective medication to relevant patients with SMI but were hampered by various challenges. These structural and contextual barriers included the following: lack of funding for chronic disease management; insufficient consultation time; workforce shortages; IT infrastructure; and navigating boundaries with mental health services. Patient-related barriers included patients' complex health and social needs, their understandable prioritisation of mental health needs or existing physical conditions, and presentation during crises. Professional barriers comprised GPs' desire to practise holistic medicine rather than treating via cardioprotective prescribing in isolation, and concerns about patients' medication concordance if patients were not prioritising this aspect of their health care at that particular time. In terms of enablers for cardioprotective prescribing, participants emphasised continuity of care as fundamental in engaging this patient group in effective cardiovascular health management. A cross-cutting theme was the current GP workforce crisis leading to 'firefighting' and diminishing capacity for primary prevention. This was particularly acute in Deep End practices, which have a high proportion of patients with complex needs and greater resource challenges.
Although participants aspire to prescribe cardioprotective medication to patients with SMI, professional-, system- and patient-level barriers often make this challenging, particularly in deprived areas owing to patient complexity and the inverse care law.
重度精神疾病(SMI)患者的死亡时间比普通人群早10至20年。他们患心血管疾病(CVD)的风险更高,但接受心脏保护药物治疗的处方率可能较低。
了解全科医生(GP)在为SMI患者开具心脏保护药物时所面临的挑战。
一项定性研究,对来自苏格兰两个卫生委员会11家诊所的15名全科医生进行了调查,其中包括为高度贫困地区(“深度贫困地区”)提供服务的诊所。
对具有SMI患者临床经验的全科医生进行一对一的半结构化访谈。访谈内容逐字记录,并进行主题分析。
参与者的目标是为相关的SMI患者常规开具心脏保护药物,但受到各种挑战的阻碍。这些结构和背景障碍包括:慢性病管理缺乏资金;咨询时间不足;劳动力短缺;信息技术基础设施;以及与精神卫生服务机构的界限划分。与患者相关的障碍包括患者复杂的健康和社会需求、他们对精神健康需求或现有身体状况的合理优先排序,以及在危机期间的就诊情况。专业障碍包括全科医生希望提供整体医疗服务,而不是孤立地通过开具心脏保护药物进行治疗,以及担心如果患者在特定时间没有将这方面的医疗保健作为优先事项,患者的药物依从性会受到影响。在心脏保护药物处方的促进因素方面,参与者强调持续护理是让这一患者群体参与有效心血管健康管理的基础。一个贯穿各领域的主题是当前全科医生劳动力危机导致“救火式”工作,以及初级预防能力的下降。这在“深度贫困地区”的诊所尤为严重,这些诊所中需求复杂的患者比例较高,资源挑战也更大。
尽管参与者渴望为SMI患者开具心脏保护药物,但专业、系统和患者层面的障碍往往使其具有挑战性,特别是在贫困地区,由于患者情况复杂以及医疗资源分配不均问题,情况更是如此。