Health Promotion Division, Public Health Foundation of India, New Delhi, Delhi, India
Health Promotion Division, Public Health Foundation of India, New Delhi, Delhi, India.
BMJ Open. 2024 Feb 13;14(2):e078749. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-078749.
Indian adolescents experience several health challenges requiring acceptable, equitable, appropriate and effective healthcare services. Our objective was to assess the compliance of Adolescent Friendly Health Clinics (AFHCs) in two of India's largest states, using both national benchmarks (under Rashtriya Kishor Swasthya Karyakram-RKSK) and global standards (by WHO).
Cross-sectional study comprising structured observations and interactions (November 2021 to June 2022).
Fourteen AFHCs across all levels of health system were included from two districts of Maharashtra (n=8) and Madhya Pradesh (n=6). These AFHCs were observed using checklist, and few items of checklist were verified by interactions with AFHC's health workers (medical officers/auxillary nurse midwives/counsellors) handlings adolescents. The developed checklist included 57 items based on adapted global standards and 25 items using national benchmarks.
High compliance of AFHCs with RKSK's benchmarks was attributed to various items including the accessibility through local transport (n=14, 100%), clean surroundings (n=11, 78.5%), presence of signage (n=10, 71.4%), convenient operating days and time (n=11, 78.5%), and secure storage of records (n=13, 92.9%). Concurrently, items that showed low compliance encompassed, the availability of Information, Education and communication (IEC) resources, which were deficient in 57.1% of AFHCs (n=8). Similarly, designated areas for clinical services (n=10, 71.4%) and commodity disbursement (n=9, 64.3%) lacked in more than half of the recruited AFHCs. Additionally, lack of guidelines for referrals (n=13, 92.9%), as well as standard operating procedures to ensure equity, non-judgemental attitude, competence, confidentiality and referral as per WHO standards.
Evidence spotlights the strengths and gaps in AFHCs, aligning with, government's priorities on adolescent health. Addressing the identified gaps is crucial to creating healthcare facilities that are adolescent-friendly, easily accessible and effectively navigate adolescent health challenges. This concerted effort would contribute to their development and transformation, playing a pivotal role in India's progress.
印度青少年面临着多种健康挑战,需要获得可接受、公平、适当和有效的医疗保健服务。我们的目标是评估印度两个最大邦的青少年友好健康诊所(AFHCs)的依从性,使用国家基准(根据 Rashtriya Kishor Swasthya Karyakram-RKSK)和全球标准(世界卫生组织)。
包括结构观察和互动的横断面研究(2021 年 11 月至 2022 年 6 月)。
从马哈拉施特拉邦(n=8)和中央邦(n=6)的两个区纳入了四级卫生系统中的 14 个 AFHCs。使用清单对这些 AFHC 进行观察,并通过与 AFHC 的卫生工作者(医生/辅助护士助产士/辅导员)处理青少年的互动来验证清单中的少数项目。制定的清单包括基于适应的全球标准的 57 个项目和使用国家基准的 25 个项目。
AFHC 高度遵守 RKSK 基准归因于各种项目,包括通过当地交通的可及性(n=14,100%)、清洁的环境(n=11,78.5%)、标识的存在(n=10,71.4%)、方便的运营日和时间(n=11,78.5%)以及记录的安全存储(n=13,92.9%)。同时,表现出低依从性的项目包括信息、教育和交流(IEC)资源的可用性,在 57.1%的 AFHC 中存在不足(n=8)。同样,指定的临床服务区域(n=10,71.4%)和商品发放区域(n=9,64.3%)在招募的 AFHC 中超过一半都缺乏。此外,缺乏转诊指南(n=13,92.9%)以及确保公平、非评判性态度、能力、保密性和按照世卫组织标准转诊的标准操作程序。
证据突出了 AFHC 的优势和差距,与政府对青少年健康的优先事项保持一致。解决确定的差距对于创建青少年友好、易于获得且能够有效应对青少年健康挑战的医疗保健设施至关重要。这种协同努力将有助于它们的发展和转型,在印度的发展中发挥关键作用。