KIT Royal Tropical Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Fós Feminista, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2024 Feb;164 Suppl 1:21-30. doi: 10.1002/ijgo.15333.
Abortion laws are key in creating an enabling environment that facilitates the advancement of people's sexual and reproductive health and rights. Around 50 countries have liberalized their abortion laws in the last decades by adding new grounds allowing abortion. The road toward the expansion of legal abortion is a long, highly sensitive, and difficult process. The specific role of healthcare providers in influencing abortion law reforms has been scarcely studied. With the objective to better understand their (potential) roles, a qualitative study was conducted in 2021 focusing on three countries that had recently liberalized their abortion regulations: Argentina, South Korea, and Ireland. For each country, key informant interviews were conducted with actors in advocacy for legal change, the majority with healthcare providers. The study results indicate that healthcare providers can contribute to the expansion of legal abortion through their influence on public and legal debates. Healthcare providers were found to be scientifically credible and trustworthy. Their voice and argumentation counteracted anti-rights arguments and addressed information gaps, by providing specific clinical experiences and medical information. Healthcare providers amplified women's experiences through their testimonies and had entry points within governmental bodies, which facilitated their advocacy. These healthcare providers often functioned as individual operating obstetrician/gynecologists or general practitioners who were engaged in networks of health professionals or had previous advocacy experience. In a global context of social and political contention around abortion, extending the engagement of healthcare providers in law and policy deliberation on abortion appears to be useful. This requires recognizing the diversity of roles that healthcare providers can take up, creating a safe environment in which they can operate, equipping them with skills that go beyond the medical expert role and facilitating strategic partnerships that seek complementarity between multiple stakeholders, building on the uniqueness of each stakeholder's expertise.
堕胎法是创造有利环境的关键,有利于推进人民的性健康和生殖健康及权利。在过去几十年中,约有 50 个国家放宽了堕胎法,增加了允许堕胎的新理由。扩大合法堕胎的道路漫长、高度敏感且困难重重。医疗保健提供者在影响堕胎法改革方面的具体作用鲜有研究。为了更好地理解他们(潜在的)角色,我们于 2021 年进行了一项定性研究,重点关注最近放宽堕胎规定的三个国家:阿根廷、韩国和爱尔兰。对于每个国家,都对倡导法律变革的利益攸关方进行了关键人物访谈,其中大多数是医疗保健提供者。研究结果表明,医疗保健提供者可以通过影响公众和法律辩论来促进合法堕胎的扩大。医疗保健提供者被认为具有科学可信度和公信力。他们的声音和论点反驳了反权利论点,并通过提供具体的临床经验和医学信息来解决信息差距。医疗保健提供者通过证词放大了妇女的经验,并在政府机构中找到了切入点,这为他们的倡导提供了便利。这些医疗保健提供者通常是个体执业的妇产科医生或全科医生,他们参与了医疗专业人员网络,或者有过以前的倡导经验。在全球范围内,堕胎问题引发了社会和政治争议,扩大医疗保健提供者在堕胎法律和政策审议中的参与似乎是有益的。这需要认识到医疗保健提供者可以承担的角色多样性,为他们创造一个安全的运作环境,使他们具备超越医疗专家角色的技能,并促进寻求多个利益攸关方互补性的战略伙伴关系,充分利用每个利益攸关方专业知识的独特性。