Verma Akanksha, Pasricha Navbir, Chaudhary Amit, Bhatnagar Rajan, Sthapak Eti, Gaharwar Anamika
Anatomy, Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, IND.
General Medicine, T.S. Misra Medical College and Hospital, Lucknow, IND.
Cureus. 2024 Jan 16;16(1):e52353. doi: 10.7759/cureus.52353. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Anatomy is one of the most volatile subjects and needs the learner to understand and retain a lot of information and terms. It is thus very important to continuously upgrade the methodology from the traditional didactive to interactive teaching to make the student an active learner and engage him in the learning process to categorize and analyze anatomical facts and knowledge.
The study was done to compare the learning outcomes and perception of medical students towards didactic lectures and interactive quiz-based lectures in anatomy.
The study was conducted amongst the 200 Year 1 medical undergraduate students enrolled in the Department of Anatomy at Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Institute of Medical Sciences, located in Lucknow, India. The 200 students comprised 120 males (60%) and 80 females (40%). The mean age of male students was 19.67 years and of females was 19.52 years. The students were divided into two groups of hundred students each by a method of convenience sampling. Students of group I were taught by an interactive quiz-based lecture and group II by a traditional didactic lecture. A pre- and post-test were conducted for both groups and feedback for both methods was taken by using a pre-validated feedback form based on a 5-point Likert scale.
On statistical analysis, it was found that in the post-test the performance of group I taught by the interactive quiz-based study was better as compared to group II taught by traditional didactive teaching, but was not statistically significant (p=0.233, p>0.05). The feedback from students revealed that 45.9% of them strongly agreed and 44.9% agreed with the fact that quiz-based lectures are better than routine lectures.
Results of the present study clearly indicate that the introduction of quiz-based anatomy teaching for undergraduate medical students was well received and appeared to improve their learning outcomes in the form of increased attention and participation during class and would lead to better retention of the topics taught during interactive lectures. To the best of our knowledge, no previous study has been done to document the efficacy of quiz-based teaching for the subject of anatomy.
解剖学是最易变动的学科之一,需要学习者理解并记住大量信息和术语。因此,不断将教学方法从传统的讲授式升级为互动式教学非常重要,这样能让学生成为积极的学习者,并使其参与到学习过程中,对解剖学事实和知识进行分类与分析。
本研究旨在比较医学生在解剖学讲授式讲座和基于互动测验的讲座中的学习成果及看法。
该研究在印度勒克瑙市拉姆·马诺哈尔·洛希亚医学科学研究所解剖学系注册的200名一年级医学本科生中进行。这200名学生包括120名男生(60%)和80名女生(40%)。男生的平均年龄为19.67岁,女生为19.52岁。通过便利抽样法将学生分为两组,每组100人。第一组学生通过基于互动测验的讲座进行教学,第二组通过传统讲授式讲座进行教学。对两组学生都进行了课前和课后测试,并使用基于5点李克特量表的预先验证的反馈表收集两种教学方法的反馈。
经统计分析发现,在课后测试中,通过基于互动测验的学习进行教学的第一组学生的表现比通过传统讲授式教学的第二组学生更好,但差异无统计学意义(p = 0.233,p>0.05)。学生的反馈显示,45.9%的学生强烈同意,44.9%的学生同意基于测验的讲座比常规讲座更好这一事实。
本研究结果清楚地表明,为本科医学生引入基于测验的解剖学教学受到了好评,并且似乎以课堂上注意力和参与度的提高的形式改善了他们的学习成果,还将导致在互动讲座中讲授的主题得到更好的记忆。据我们所知,之前没有研究记录过基于测验的教学对解剖学学科的有效性。