Meng Guangxia, McAiney Carrie, McKillop Ian, Perlman Christopher M, Tsao Shu-Feng, Chen Helen
School of Public Health Sciences, University of Walterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada.
JMIR Cardio. 2024 Feb 16;8:e51439. doi: 10.2196/51439.
Ontario stroke prevention clinics primarily held in-person visits before the COVID-19 pandemic and then had to shift to a home-based teleconsultation delivery model using telephone or video to provide services during the pandemic. This change may have affected service quality and patient experiences.
This study seeks to understand patient satisfaction with Ontario stroke prevention clinics' rapid shift to a home-based teleconsultation delivery model used during the COVID-19 pandemic. The research question explores explanatory factors affecting patient satisfaction.
Using a cross-sectional service performance model, we surveyed patients who received telephone or video consultations at 2 Ontario stroke prevention clinics in 2021. This survey included closed- and open-ended questions. We used logistic regression and qualitative content analysis to understand factors affecting patient satisfaction with the quality of home-based teleconsultation services.
The overall response rate to the web survey was 37.2% (128/344). The quantitative analysis was based on 110 responses, whereas the qualitative analysis included 97 responses. Logistic regression results revealed that responsiveness (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] 0.034, 95% CI 0.006-0.188; P<.001) and empathy (AOR 0.116, 95% CI 0.017-0.800; P=.03) were significant factors negatively associated with low satisfaction (scores of 1, 2, or 3 out of 5). The only characteristic positively associated with low satisfaction was when survey consent was provided by the substitute decision maker (AOR 6.592, 95% CI 1.452-29.927; P=.02). In the qualitative content analysis, patients with both low and high global satisfaction scores shared the same factors of service dissatisfaction (assurance, reliability, and empathy). The main subcategories associated with dissatisfaction were missing clinical activities, inadequate communication, administrative process issues, and absence of personal connection. Conversely, the high-satisfaction group offered more positive feedback on assurance, reliability, and empathy, as well as on having a competent clinician, appropriate patient selection, and excellent communication and empathy skills.
The insights gained from this study can be considered when designing home-based teleconsultation services to enhance patient experiences in stroke prevention care.
安大略省的中风预防诊所主要在2019冠状病毒病大流行之前进行面对面就诊,然后在大流行期间不得不转向使用电话或视频的居家远程会诊服务模式。这一变化可能影响了服务质量和患者体验。
本研究旨在了解患者对安大略省中风预防诊所在2019冠状病毒病大流行期间迅速转向居家远程会诊服务模式的满意度。该研究问题探讨了影响患者满意度的解释性因素。
我们采用横断面服务绩效模型,对2021年在安大略省两家中风预防诊所接受电话或视频会诊的患者进行了调查。该调查包括封闭式和开放式问题。我们使用逻辑回归和定性内容分析来了解影响患者对居家远程会诊服务质量满意度的因素。
网络调查的总体回复率为37.2%(128/344)。定量分析基于110份回复,而定性分析包括97份回复。逻辑回归结果显示,响应性(调整后的优势比[AOR]为0.034,95%置信区间为0.006-0.188;P<.001)和同理心(AOR为0.116,95%置信区间为0.017-0.800;P=.03)是与低满意度(5分制中的1、2或3分)呈负相关的显著因素。与低满意度呈正相关的唯一特征是替代决策者提供调查同意书(AOR为6.592,95%置信区间为1.452-29.927;P=.02)。在定性内容分析中,总体满意度得分低和高的患者都存在相同的服务不满意因素(保证、可靠性和同理心)。与不满意相关的主要子类别包括错过临床活动、沟通不足、行政流程问题以及缺乏人际联系。相反,高满意度组在保证、可靠性和同理心方面,以及在有能力的临床医生、合适的患者选择、出色的沟通和同理心技能方面提供了更多积极反馈。
在设计居家远程会诊服务以改善中风预防护理中的患者体验时,可以考虑本研究获得的见解。