Nabelsi Veronique, Plouffe Véronique, Leclerc Marie Chantal
Département des sciences administratives, Université du Québec, Québec, Canada.
Département des sciences comptables, Université du Québec en Outaouais, Gatineau, Canada.
JMIR Aging. 2025 May 7;8:e71950. doi: 10.2196/71950.
Teleconsultation has expanded rapidly in recent years, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, and has become standard practice among physicians. The benefits of teleconsultation, namely, improving access to care, ensuring continuity and quality of care, increasing patient satisfaction, and reducing costs and wait times, are well documented. However, its use in nursing practice, especially in long-term care settings, remains underresearched despite its significant transformative potential, particularly in resource-limited and rural settings, where it could address major challenges such as nursing shortages and access to care.
This study aimed to identify barriers to and facilitators of implementing overnight nursing teleconsultation in rural residential and long-term care centers in Quebec, Canada (centres d'hébergement et de soins de longue durée [CHSLDs]), with ≤50 beds.
A 6-month pilot project was rolled out sequentially in 3 rural CHSLDs in 2 administrative regions of Quebec between July 2022 and March 2023. A total of 38 semistructured interviews were conducted with managers (n=27, 71%), nursing staff members (n=9, 24%), and resident committee presidents (n=2, 5%) between February 2023 and July 2023.
The study identified several barriers to the implementation of teleconsultation. The main barriers reported included union opposition (managers: 23/27, 85%), network instability (resident committee presidents: 2/2, 100%), limited technology skills (nursing staff members: 7/9, 78%), a perceived increase in workload (nursing staff members: 8/9, 89%; resident committee presidents: 2/2, 100%), and a low volume of teleconsultations (nursing staff members: 8/9, 89%). Despite the barriers, participants also identified key facilitators. These included the care setting (nursing staff members: 9/9, 100%; managers: 21/27, 78%), buy-in from senior management and managers (managers: 27/27, 100%; resident committee presidents: 2/2, 100%), collaboration between the departments (nursing staff members: 9/9, 100%), nursing staff motivation (nursing staff members: 9/9, 100%), and improvements in professional practices (nursing staff members: 8/9, 89%). Finally, the relative benefits of teleconsultation, such as enhanced mutual vision, faster assessment of clinical situations, improved resident care management quality, and greater flexibility and safety, were unanimously recognized (38/38, 100%) as contributing to its acceptability and potential for success.
This study provides an in-depth understanding of the barriers to and facilitators of implementing overnight nursing teleconsultation in small rural CHSLDs. This constitutes a sound basis for developing tailored strategies aimed at overcoming identified barriers and optimizing facilitators. The results also provide practical guidelines for decision makers, highlighting the need to adapt implementation approaches to the unique context of each facility. Furthermore, this study highlights the importance of further research to broaden our knowledge on the dissemination and scale-up of health care innovations. This includes the development of learning health systems capable of responding in an agile and effective way to the needs of rural and vulnerable populations both in Quebec and elsewhere.
近年来,远程会诊发展迅速,尤其是在新冠疫情期间,已成为医生的标准做法。远程会诊的益处,即改善医疗服务可及性、确保医疗服务的连续性和质量、提高患者满意度以及降低成本和等待时间,已有充分记录。然而,尽管其具有巨大的变革潜力,尤其是在资源有限的农村地区,远程会诊在护理实践中的应用,特别是在长期护理环境中的应用,仍未得到充分研究,而在这些地区,它可以应对诸如护理短缺和医疗服务可及性等重大挑战。
本研究旨在确定在加拿大魁北克省床位≤50张的农村寄宿和长期护理中心(长期护理中心)实施夜间护理远程会诊的障碍和促进因素。
2022年7月至2023年3月期间,在魁北克省2个行政区的3个农村长期护理中心依次开展了为期6个月的试点项目。2023年2月至7月期间,共对管理人员(n = 27,71%)、护理人员(n = 9,24%)和居民委员会主席(n = 2,5%)进行了38次半结构化访谈。
该研究确定了远程会诊实施的几个障碍。报告的主要障碍包括工会反对(管理人员:23/27,85%)、网络不稳定(居民委员会主席:2/2,100%)、技术技能有限(护理人员:7/9,78%)、工作量增加的感觉(护理人员:8/9,89%;居民委员会主席:2/2,100%)以及远程会诊量少(护理人员:8/9,89%)。尽管存在障碍,参与者也确定了关键的促进因素。这些因素包括护理环境(护理人员:9/9,100%;管理人员:21/27,78%)、高级管理层和管理人员的支持(管理人员:27/27,100%;居民委员会主席:2/2,100%)、部门间协作(护理人员:9/9,100%)、护理人员的积极性(护理人员:9/9,100%)以及专业实践改进(护理人员:8/9,89%)。最后,远程会诊的相对益处得到了一致认可(38/38,100%),如增强相互视野、更快评估临床情况、提高居民护理管理质量以及更大的灵活性和安全性,这些都有助于其可接受性和成功潜力。
本研究深入了解了在小型农村长期护理中心实施夜间护理远程会诊的障碍和促进因素。这为制定旨在克服已确定障碍并优化促进因素的针对性策略奠定了坚实基础。研究结果还为决策者提供了实用指南,强调需要根据每个机构的独特情况调整实施方法。此外,本研究强调了进一步研究以拓宽我们对医疗保健创新传播和扩大规模的认识的重要性。这包括发展能够灵活有效地应对魁北克及其他地区农村和弱势群体需求的学习型卫生系统。