Treufeldt Hõbe, Burton Christopher
Division of Population Health, University of Sheffield, Samuel Fox House, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield S5 7AU, UK.
Division of Population Health, University of Sheffield, Samuel Fox House, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield S5 7AU, UK.
Patient Educ Couns. 2024 Jun;123:108198. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2024.108198. Epub 2024 Feb 7.
To conduct a scoping review of stigma in medical encounters for persistent physical symptoms and functional disorders (PPS/FD). Stigma is a social attribute that links a person to an undesirable characteristic. It has been extensively studied in relation to mental illness but less so in relation to PPS/FD.
We followed PRISMA-ScR reporting guidelines for scoping reviews. Searches for were designed using the SPIDER tool. We used descriptive and thematic analysis.
The searches identified 68 articles, of which 32 were eligible for inclusion. 31 out of the 32 studies used a qualitative methodology. 8 studies used an explicit definition of stigma, of which 6 used the Goffman (1963) definition. Only 2 studies directly examined clinical consultations, the remainder relied on recalled accounts by patients or professionals. Descriptive analysis identified the focus of the studies included: patient-physician interaction (n = 13); health care professionals' perceptions (n = 7); experiences of illness/stigma (n = 6); broader meaning of illness (n = 3); and patients' experiences of stigma in health care consultations (n = 3).
Patients experience stigmatisation in consultations for a wide range of PPS/FD. This suggests the presence of structural stigmatisation.
There is a need for effective stigma reduction strategies in consultations about persistent physical symptoms.
对持续性身体症状和功能障碍(PPS/FD)医疗问诊中的污名化进行范围综述。污名是一种将个人与不良特征联系起来的社会属性。它在精神疾病方面已得到广泛研究,但在PPS/FD方面的研究较少。
我们遵循PRISMA-ScR报告指南进行范围综述。使用SPIDER工具设计检索策略。我们采用描述性和主题分析方法。
检索到68篇文章,其中32篇符合纳入标准。32项研究中有31项采用定性研究方法。8项研究对污名进行了明确界定,其中6项采用了戈夫曼(1963年)的定义。只有2项研究直接考察了临床会诊,其余研究依赖于患者或专业人员的回忆叙述。描述性分析确定研究重点包括:医患互动(n = 13);医疗保健专业人员的认知(n = 7);疾病/污名的经历(n = 6);疾病的更广泛含义(n = 3);以及患者在医疗保健会诊中的污名经历(n = 3)。
患者在多种PPS/FD的会诊中都经历了污名化。这表明存在结构性污名。
在关于持续性身体症状的会诊中,需要有效的减少污名策略。