Khayyat Sarah M
Department of Clinical Pharmacy, College of Pharmacy, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia.
Saudi Pharm J. 2024 Mar;32(3):101981. doi: 10.1016/j.jsps.2024.101981. Epub 2024 Feb 7.
Identifying and prioritizing criteria for referring patients to a counseling clinic managed by hospital pharmacists in the tertiary care setting in Saudi Arabia (SA).
A two-phase consensus Delphi methodological approach was adopted in this study. Data was collected from physicians and pharmacists from different specialties working in different hospitals in Makkah City. In Phase 1, semi-structured interviews were conducted with physicians and pharmacists to discuss and develop the initial list of potential referral criteria for post-discharge counseling. Phase 2 consisted of two rounds of online surveys where participants were asked to independently rank the referral criteria using a 5-point Likert Scale.
In Phase 1, four participants undertook the interviews (two physicians and two pharmacists). Overall, no major comments were given on the suggested criteria. In Phase 2, most suggested referral criteria to the counseling clinic reached participants' consensus agreement of >70 % in both rounds for all three domains. Among all criteria that achieved consensus agreement, two demographic criteria were top-ranked by the participants; the elderly patients (100 %) and those who needed help with their devices (96 %). These were followed by five medication-related criteria, which are medication-related problems, polypharmacy, medication that needs monitoring, high-risk medication, and medication with special formulations. All had a consensus agreement of 96 %.
This study suggests that a counseling clinic led by pharmacists is particularly advisable for the elderly, individuals requiring assistance with their devices, and those encountering medication issues. It is essential to prioritize specific patient demographics when contemplating the extensive establishment and integration of such clinics across various hospitals in SA.
识别并确定沙特阿拉伯(SA)三级医疗环境下将患者转诊至由医院药剂师管理的咨询诊所的标准,并对这些标准进行优先级排序。
本研究采用两阶段共识德尔菲法。数据收集自麦加市不同医院的不同专业的医生和药剂师。在第一阶段,对医生和药剂师进行半结构化访谈,以讨论并制定出院后咨询潜在转诊标准的初始清单。第二阶段包括两轮在线调查,要求参与者使用5点李克特量表对转诊标准进行独立排序。
在第一阶段,4名参与者接受了访谈(2名医生和2名药剂师)。总体而言,对所建议的标准未提出重大意见。在第二阶段,对于所有三个领域,大多数建议转诊至咨询诊所的标准在两轮调查中均达成了超过70%的参与者共识。在所有达成共识的标准中,有两个人口统计学标准被参与者列为最高级别;老年患者(100%)和需要设备帮助的患者(96%)。其次是五个与药物相关的标准,即药物相关问题、多重用药、需要监测的药物、高风险药物和特殊剂型药物。所有这些标准的共识率均为96%。
本研究表明,由药剂师主导的咨询诊所对老年人、需要设备帮助的个体以及遇到药物问题的人尤为适用。在考虑在沙特阿拉伯各医院广泛设立并整合此类诊所时,对特定患者人口统计学特征进行优先级排序至关重要。