Maga Giulia, Magon Arianna, Pedrina Deborah, Pappalardo Martina, Del Bo Elsa, Conte Gianluca, Caruso Rosario, Arrigoni Cristina
Dipartimento di Biomedicina e prevenzione, Università di Roma Tor Vergata.
Area di Ricerca e sviluppo delle professioni sanitarie, Irccs Policlinico San Donato, San Donato Milanese (Milano).
Recenti Prog Med. 2024 Mar;115(3):138-147. doi: 10.1701/4211.42044.
mHealth apps are the most commonly used applications by women for seeking information and support for breastfeeding. The primary goal of this study is to provide a quality assessment of Italian-language mHealth apps for breastfeeding using the Italian version of the Mobile App Rating Scale (I-MARS).
A systematic search was conducted on the Apple App Store, Google Play Store, and Windows Store. Inclusion criteria were: mHealth apps available in Italian, free of charge, and focused on the theme of breastfeeding. The quality assessment of the eligible mHealth apps was carried out on the latest available version using the I-MARS, by two authors independently.
A total of 381 mHealth apps were identified, of which 38 mHealth apps were included and evaluated (n=9 on Google Play Store, n=29 on Apple App Store). The average total score of the objective dimension of I-MARS was found to be adequate, equal to 3,07±0,75, with a Cohen's Kappa score of 65,8%. The subjective dimension of the I-MARS, however, achieved a low average total score of 2,44±1,03, with a Cohen's Kappa score of 60,5%. In this regard, the subjective dimension of the I-MARS shows lower values compared to the subjective evaluation of the users (3,28±1,95).
The informational quality dimension of mHealth apps was found to be lacking and/or inadequate in 80% of cases. 53% of the selected mHealth apps presented average quality scores that were adequate. The results of this study thus lay the groundwork for future recommendations for the development and proper use of mHealth apps for the protection, promotion, and support of breastfeeding.
移动健康应用程序是女性寻求母乳喂养信息和支持时最常用的应用程序。本研究的主要目的是使用意大利版移动应用程序评分量表(I-MARS)对意大利语的母乳喂养移动健康应用程序进行质量评估。
在苹果应用商店、谷歌Play商店和微软应用商店进行了系统搜索。纳入标准为:意大利语的移动健康应用程序、免费且专注于母乳喂养主题。由两名作者独立使用I-MARS对符合条件的移动健康应用程序的最新可用版本进行质量评估。
共识别出381个移动健康应用程序,其中38个移动健康应用程序被纳入并评估(谷歌Play商店9个,苹果应用商店29个)。发现I-MARS客观维度的平均总分足够,为3.07±0.75,科恩卡帕系数为65.8%。然而,I-MARS主观维度的平均总分较低,为2.44±1.03,科恩卡帕系数为60.5%。在这方面,I-MARS主观维度的值低于用户的主观评价(3.28±1.95)。
在80%的案例中,发现移动健康应用程序的信息质量维度存在不足和/或不充分的情况。53%的选定移动健康应用程序的平均质量得分足够。因此,本研究结果为未来开发和正确使用移动健康应用程序以保护、促进和支持母乳喂养的建议奠定了基础。