Department of Bioengineering, Clemson University, Clemson, SC, USA; The Clemson University-Medical University of South Carolina Bioengineering Program, Charleston, SC, USA.
Department of Bioengineering, Clemson University, Clemson, SC, USA; The Clemson University-Medical University of South Carolina Bioengineering Program, Charleston, SC, USA.
Acta Biomater. 2024 Apr 1;178:352-365. doi: 10.1016/j.actbio.2024.02.028. Epub 2024 Feb 27.
Ti-6Al-4V selective dissolution occurs in vivo on orthopedic implants as the leading edge of a pitting corrosion attack. A gap persists in our fundamental understanding of selective dissolution and pre-clinical tests fail to reproduce this damage. While CoCrMo clinical use decreases, Ti-6Al-4V and the crevice geometries where corrosion can occur remain ubiquitous in implant design. Additionally, most additively manufactured devices cleared by the FDA use Ti-6Al-4V. Accelerated preclinical testing, therefore, would aid in the evaluation of new titanium devices and biomaterials. In this study, using temperature, we (1) developed an accelerated pre-clinical methodology to rapidly induce dissolution and (2) investigated the structure-property relationship between the dissolving surface and the oxide layer. We hypothesized that solution temperature and HO concentration would accelerate oxide degradation, increase corrosion kinetics and decrease experimental times. To assess this effect, we selected temperatures above (45 °C), below (24 °C), and at (37 °C) physiological levels. Then, we acquired electrochemical impedance spectra during active β dissolution, showing significant decreases in oxide polarization resistance (R) both over time (p = 0.000) and as temperature increased (p = 0.000). Next, using the impedance response as a guide, we quantified the extent of selective dissolution in scanning electron micrographs. As the temperature increased, the corrosion rate increased in an Arrhenius-dependent manner. Last, we identified three surface classes as the oxide properties changed: undissolved, transition and dissolved. These results indicate a concentration and temperature dependent structure-property relationship between the solution, the protective oxide film, and the substrate alloy. Additionally, we show how supraphysiological temperatures induce structurally similar dissolution to tests run at 37 °C in less experimental time. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Within modular taper junctions of total hip replacement systems, retrieval studies document severe corrosion including Ti-6AL-4V selective dissolution. Current pre-clinical tests and ASTM standards fail to reproduce this damage, preventing accurate screening of titanium-based biomaterials and implant designs. In this study, we induce selective dissolution using accelerated temperatures. Building off previous work, we use electrochemical impedance spectroscopy to rapidly monitor the oxide film during dissolution. We elucidate components of the dissolution mechanism, where oxide degradation precedes pit nucleation within the β phase. Using an Arrhenius approach, we relate these accelerated testing conditions to more physiologically relevant solution concentrations. In total, this study shows the importance of including adverse electrochemical events like cathodic activation and inflammatory species in pre-clinical testing.
Ti-6Al-4V 在骨科植入物中会发生选择性溶解,成为点蚀攻击的前缘。我们对选择性溶解的基本理解存在差距,临床前测试未能重现这种损伤。虽然 CoCrMo 的临床应用减少了,但 Ti-6Al-4V 以及可能发生腐蚀的缝隙几何形状仍然在植入物设计中无处不在。此外,大多数通过 FDA 批准的增材制造设备都使用 Ti-6Al-4V。因此,加速临床前测试将有助于评估新的钛设备和生物材料。在这项研究中,我们(1)利用温度开发了一种加速的临床前方法来快速诱导溶解,(2)研究了溶解表面和氧化物层之间的结构-性能关系。我们假设溶液温度和 HO 浓度会加速氧化物降解、增加腐蚀动力学并缩短实验时间。为了评估这种效果,我们选择了高于(45°C)、低于(24°C)和(37°C)生理水平的温度。然后,我们在活性β溶解过程中获得了电化学阻抗谱,显示出氧化物极化电阻(R)随着时间(p=0.000)和温度升高(p=0.000)的显著降低。接下来,我们利用阻抗响应作为指导,在扫描电子显微镜下定量评估选择性溶解的程度。随着温度的升高,腐蚀速率呈阿伦尼乌斯依赖性增加。最后,我们确定了三种表面类型,因为氧化物的性质发生了变化:未溶解、过渡和溶解。这些结果表明,溶液、保护性氧化膜和基底合金之间存在浓度和温度依赖的结构-性能关系。此外,我们展示了如何在更短的实验时间内,用超生理温度诱导与在 37°C 下运行的测试结构相似的溶解。 意义声明:在全髋关节置换系统的模块化锥度接头内,检索研究记录了严重的腐蚀,包括 Ti-6AL-4V 的选择性溶解。当前的临床前测试和 ASTM 标准未能重现这种损伤,从而无法准确筛选钛基生物材料和植入物设计。在这项研究中,我们使用加速温度诱导选择性溶解。在此基础上,我们使用电化学阻抗谱在溶解过程中快速监测氧化物膜。我们阐明了溶解机制的组成部分,其中氧化物降解先于β相中蚀坑的成核。我们采用阿仑尼乌斯方法将这些加速测试条件与更生理相关的溶液浓度联系起来。总的来说,这项研究表明在临床前测试中纳入阴极激活和炎症物质等不利电化学事件的重要性。