Departments of1Neurosurgery and.
2Department of Neurosurgery, Neuromed Campus, Kepler University Hospital, Linz, Austria.
Neurosurg Focus. 2024 Mar;56(3):E2. doi: 10.3171/2024.1.FOCUS23767.
In contrast to high-grade dural arteriovenous fistula (dAVF), low-grade dAVF is mainly associated with tinnitus and carries a low risk of morbidity and mortality. It remains unclear whether the benefits of active interventions outweigh the associated risk of complications in low-grade dAVF.
The authors conducted a retrospective single-center study that included all consecutive patients diagnosed with an intracranial low-grade dAVF (Cognard type I and IIa) during 2012-2022 with DSA. The authors analyzed symptom relief, symptomatic angiographic cure, treatment-related complications, risk for intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), and mortality. All patients were followed up until the end of 2022.
A total of 81 patients were diagnosed with a low-grade dAVF. Of these, 48 patients (59%) underwent treatment (all primary endovascular treatments), and 33 patients (41%) did not undergo treatment. Nine patients (19%) underwent retreatments. Angiographic follow-up was performed after median (IQR) 7.7 (6.1-24.1) months by means of DSA (mean 15.0, median 6.4 months, range 4.5-83.4 months) or MRA (mean 29.3, median 24.7 months, range 5.9-62.1 months). Symptom control was achieved in 98% of treated patients after final treatment. On final angiographic follow-up, 73% of patients had a completely occluded dAVF. There were 2 treatment-related complications resulting in 1 transient (2%) and 1 permanent (2%) neurological complication. One patient showed recurrence and progression of a completely occluded low-grade dAVF to an asymptomatic high-grade dAVF. No cases of ICH- or dAVF-related mortality were found in either treated patients (median [IQR] follow-up 5.1 [2.0-6.8] years) or untreated patients (median [IQR] follow-up 5.7 [3.2-9.0] years).
Treatment of low-grade dAVF provides a high rate of symptom relief with small risks for complications with neurological sequela. The risks of ICH and mortality in patients with untreated low-grade dAVF are minimal. Symptoms may not reveal high-grade recurrence, and radiological follow-up may be warranted in selected patients with treated low-grade dAVF. An optimal radiographic follow-up regimen should be developed by a future prospective multicenter registry.
与高级硬脑膜动静脉瘘(dAVF)相比,低级 dAVF 主要与耳鸣有关,其发病率和死亡率较低。目前尚不清楚在低级 dAVF 中,积极干预的益处是否超过并发症相关风险。
作者进行了一项回顾性单中心研究,该研究纳入了 2012 年至 2022 年间在本院接受数字减影血管造影(DSA)检查并确诊为颅内低级 dAVF(Cognard 1 型和 2a 型)的所有连续患者。作者分析了症状缓解、症状性血管造影治愈、治疗相关并发症、颅内出血(ICH)风险和死亡率。所有患者均随访至 2022 年底。
共 81 例患者被诊断为低级 dAVF,其中 48 例(59%)接受了治疗(均为初次血管内治疗),33 例(41%)未接受治疗。9 例(19%)接受了再治疗。中位(IQR)7.7(6.1-24.1)个月后通过 DSA(平均 15.0,中位数 6.4 个月,范围 4.5-83.4 个月)或磁共振血管造影(MRA)(平均 29.3,中位数 24.7 个月,范围 5.9-62.1 个月)进行血管造影随访。最终治疗后,98%的治疗患者症状得到控制。最终血管造影随访时,73%的患者 dAVF 完全闭塞。有 2 例治疗相关并发症,导致 1 例短暂(2%)和 1 例永久性(2%)神经并发症。1 例患者完全闭塞的低级 dAVF复发并进展为无症状的高级 dAVF。在治疗患者(中位[IQR]随访 5.1[2.0-6.8]年)或未治疗患者(中位[IQR]随访 5.7[3.2-9.0]年)中均未发现 ICH 或 dAVF 相关死亡率。
治疗低级 dAVF 可提供高症状缓解率,并发症相关神经后遗症风险小。未治疗的低级 dAVF 患者发生 ICH 和死亡的风险极小。症状可能不会提示高级复发,对于接受治疗的低级 dAVF 患者,可能需要进行影像学随访。未来的多中心前瞻性登记研究应制定最佳的影像学随访方案。