Keremoğlu Eda, Weidmann Nils B, Gamero-Garrido Alexander, Carisimo Esteban, Dainotti Alberto, Snoeren Alex C
Department of Politics and Public Administration, University of Konstanz, 78457 Konstanz, Germany.
Department of Computer Science, University of California, Davis, CA 95616-5270, USA.
PNAS Nexus. 2024 Feb 14;3(3):pgae069. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae069. eCollection 2024 Mar.
Recent years have seen an increase in governmental interference in digital communication. Most research on this topic has focused on the application level, studying how content is manipulated or removed on websites, blogs, or social media. However, in order for governments to obtain and maintain control of digital data flows, they need to secure access to the network infrastructure at the level of Internet service providers. In this paper, we study how the network topology of the Internet varies across different political environments, distinguishing between control at the level of individual Internet users (access) and a higher level in the hierarchy of network carriers (transit). Using a novel method to estimate the structure of the Internet from network measurements, we show that in autocratic countries, state-owned (rather than privately owned) providers have a markedly higher degree of control over transit networks. We also show that state-owned Internet providers often provide Internet access abroad, with a clear focus on other autocratic countries. Together, these results suggest that in autocracies, the network infrastructure is organized in a way that is more susceptible to the monitoring and manipulation of Internet data flows by state-owned providers both domestically and abroad.
近年来,政府对数字通信的干预有所增加。关于这一主题的大多数研究都集中在应用层面,研究内容是如何在网站、博客或社交媒体上对内容进行操控或删除。然而,为了让政府获取并维持对数字数据流的控制,它们需要在互联网服务提供商层面确保对网络基础设施的访问。在本文中,我们研究互联网的网络拓扑结构在不同政治环境下是如何变化的,区分个体互联网用户层面(接入)的控制和网络运营商层级中更高层面(转接)的控制。通过一种利用网络测量来估计互联网结构的新颖方法,我们发现,在专制国家,国有(而非私有)提供商对转接网络的控制程度明显更高。我们还表明,国有互联网提供商经常在国外提供互联网接入服务,且明显侧重于其他专制国家。综合来看,这些结果表明,在专制体制下,网络基础设施的组织方式使得国内外的国有提供商更容易对互联网数据流进行监控和操控。