Teaching and Learning Innovation Centre, Faculty of Education, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Department of Curriculum and Instruction, Faculty of Education, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2024 Jun;94(2):622-641. doi: 10.1111/bjep.12670. Epub 2024 Mar 5.
Socio-emotional skills are critical to life outcomes such as achievement, well-being and job success. However, existing research has mostly focused on the consequences of socio-emotional skills, with less attention devoted to the role of school climate in the deployment of these skills.
This study investigated the role of school climate in socio-emotional skills. More specifically, we investigated whether cooperative or competitive school climates are associated with students' socio-emotional skills.
Our study utilized data from the OECD Survey on Social and Emotional Skills, collected from 10 cities across nine countries. Participants were 60,985 students, including 31,187 10-year-olds (49.70% females) and 29,798 15-year-olds (51.6% females).
We conducted multilevel structural equation modelling to test whether cooperative and competitive climates were associated with socio-emotional skills. These skills include five broad domain skills and 15 more specific skills: task performance (self-control, responsibility and persistence), emotion regulation (stress resistance, emotional control and optimism), collaboration (empathy, trust and cooperation), open-mindedness (tolerance, curiosity and creativity) and engaging with others (sociability, assertiveness and energy).
Our findings indicated a positive relationship between a cooperative climate and socio-emotional skills. In contrast, the relationship between a competitive climate and socio-emotional skills was primarily negative.
This study highlights the contrasting roles of cooperative and competitive climates in students' socio-emotional skills.
社会情感技能对于成就、幸福和工作成功等生活结果至关重要。然而,现有研究大多集中在社会情感技能的后果上,而较少关注学校氛围在这些技能的运用中的作用。
本研究探讨了学校氛围在社会情感技能中的作用。更具体地说,我们调查了合作或竞争的学校氛围是否与学生的社会情感技能有关。
我们的研究利用了经合组织社会和情感技能调查的数据,该调查收集了来自九个国家的十个城市的数据。参与者为 60985 名学生,包括 31187 名 10 岁学生(49.70%为女性)和 29798 名 15 岁学生(51.6%为女性)。
我们进行了多层次结构方程建模,以检验合作和竞争氛围是否与社会情感技能相关。这些技能包括五个广泛的领域技能和 15 个更具体的技能:任务表现(自我控制、责任感和毅力)、情绪调节(抗压能力、情绪控制和乐观主义)、合作(同理心、信任和合作)、开放思维(宽容、好奇心和创造力)和与他人交往(社交能力、自信和活力)。
我们的研究结果表明,合作氛围与社会情感技能呈正相关。相比之下,竞争氛围与社会情感技能的关系主要是负面的。
本研究强调了合作和竞争氛围在学生社会情感技能中的不同作用。