From the School of Medicine, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA (MBP, JYT, KL, JP, DH); King's College, London, UK (VB).
J Am Board Fam Med. 2024 Mar 11;37(1):84-94. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2023.230239R1.
Cigarette smoking rates remain disproportionately high among low income populations with unmet social and behavioral health needs. To address this problem, we sought to develop and evaluate the feasibility, acceptability, and preliminary effectiveness of a novel smoking cessation program for community health centers that serve these populations.
We implemented a randomized pilot trial of two smoking cessation programs in three county operated community health center (CHC) sites: (1) a systematic assessment of smoking habits and standard tools to assist with smoking cessation counseling ("Enhanced Standard Program" or ESP), and (2) another that added a structured assessment of social and behavioral barriers to smoking cessation, ("Connection to Health for Smokers" or CTHS). Clinical outcomes were evaluated between 10 to 16 weeks, supplemented with interviews of patient participants and health care team members.
141 adults were randomized and 123 completed the intervention (61 in ESP, 62 in CTHS). At follow-up, over half of participants reported ≥1 quit attempts (59.7% ESP and 56.5% CTHS; adjusted = .66) while more in ESP (24.6% vs. 12.9%) were documented as not smoking in the last 7 days (adjusted = 0.03). In addition to being in ESP, predictors of smoking cessation included higher baseline confidence in ability to quit ( = 0.02) and more quit attempts during the study ( = 0.04). Health care teams, however, generally preferred the more comprehensive approach of CTHS.
Lessons learned from this pilot study may inform the development of effective smoking cessation programs for CHCs that combine elements of both interventions.
在社会和行为健康需求未得到满足的低收入人群中,吸烟率仍然居高不下。为了解决这个问题,我们试图为服务于这些人群的社区卫生中心开发和评估一种新的戒烟计划的可行性、可接受性和初步效果。
我们在三个县运营的社区卫生中心(CHC)地点实施了两项戒烟计划的随机试点试验:(1)对吸烟习惯进行系统评估和标准工具,以协助戒烟咨询(“增强标准计划”或 ESP),(2)另一个增加了对戒烟的社会和行为障碍的结构化评估(“吸烟者的健康连接”或 CTHS)。临床结果在 10 至 16 周之间进行评估,并补充了患者参与者和医疗保健团队成员的访谈。
141 名成年人被随机分组,123 名完成了干预(ESP 组 61 名,CTHS 组 62 名)。在随访时,超过一半的参与者报告至少有一次戒烟尝试(ESP 组为 59.7%,CTHS 组为 56.5%;调整后=0.66),而在 ESP 组中,有更多的人(24.6%比 12.9%)被记录为在过去 7 天内不吸烟(调整后=0.03)。除了参与 ESP 外,戒烟的预测因素包括更高的戒烟能力基线信心(=0.02)和研究期间更多的戒烟尝试(=0.04)。然而,医疗保健团队普遍更喜欢 CTHS 的更全面方法。
从这项试点研究中吸取的经验教训可能为 CHC 开发有效的戒烟计划提供信息,这些计划结合了两种干预措施的元素。