Equipo Psicosocial-Unidad Forense de Valoración Integral, Instituto de Medicina Legal y Ciencias Forenses de Albacete, Cuenca y Guadalajara. Subdirección de Cuenca. Ministerio de Justicia, Spain.
Unidad de Psicología Cognitiva Aplicada, IDINE, Spain; Facultad de Educación de Albacete, Spain.
Int J Law Psychiatry. 2024 May-Jun;94:101972. doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2024.101972. Epub 2024 Mar 8.
When an alleged victim has a pre-existing psychopathological diagnosis, this can affect the rating of their version of the abuse in terms of credibility. The objective of this work is to analyze the relationship between the assessment of the credibility of the testimony of a CSA victim, the psychological problems that the child may have presented prior to sexual abuse and the possible psychological sequelae that she may present as a result of the abuse. 109 cases were selected in which the credibility of the testimony could be determined. Through forensic interviews and the study of the corresponding professional reports, the following were obtained: sociodemographic data, data on their previous psychological state and data on their psychological state after the reported events. The psychological state of the child after the reported events shows no relation to the forensic evaluation of the credibility of her testimony. The existence of a relationship between the absence of previous psychopathology and the fact that the victim's testimony is valued as a credible account is confirmed. This study reveals that children who presented psychological manifestations prior to their experience of abuse receive a lower credibility rating than those without previous psychopathological symptoms or diagnoses.
当被指控的受害者有预先存在的精神病理学诊断时,这可能会影响对其虐待版本的可信度的评估。这项工作的目的是分析 CSA 受害者证词可信度评估、儿童在遭受性虐待之前可能出现的心理问题以及她可能因虐待而出现的潜在心理后果之间的关系。选择了 109 例可以确定证词可信度的案例。通过法医访谈和相应专业报告的研究,获得了以下数据:社会人口统计学数据、他们以前的心理状态数据以及报告事件后心理状态数据。报告事件后儿童的心理状态与对其证词可信度的法医评估无关。确认了先前精神病理学缺失与受害者证词被视为可信陈述之间存在关系的存在。这项研究表明,与没有先前精神病理学症状或诊断的儿童相比,经历过虐待前出现心理表现的儿童的可信度评级较低。