Khoramian Esfahani Mina Sadat, Ahmadi Ghazaleh, Esmaeili Behnaz
Student Research Committee, Health Research Institute, Babol University of Medical Sciences, Babol, I.R. Iran.
Dental Materials Research Center, Health Research Institute, Babol University of Medical Sciences, Babol, I.R. Iran.
Dent Res J (Isfahan). 2024 Feb 22;21:18. eCollection 2024.
This study aimed to assess the effect of polishing versus glazing of computer-aided design-computer-aided manufacturing (CAD-CAM) ceramics on depth of wear and surface roughness of opposing composite resin.
This study was conducted on 40 Z250 composite and 40 CAD-CAM ceramic specimens including Celtra Duo, Vita Mark II, e.max CAD, and Vita Suprinity ceramics. All ceramic specimens were roughened by a fine-grit bur after primary glazing to simulate an adjusted surface in the clinical setting. They were then randomly assigned to two subgroups and underwent reglazing or polishing. All composite and ceramic specimens underwent profilometry after surface treatment and prior to the wear test, and the results were recorded quantitatively. Composite specimens were then subjected to 120,000 wear cycles against ceramic specimens in a chewing simulator, and the depth of wear was measured by a scanner. Data were statistically analyzed by repeated measures two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and one-way ANOVA (α = 0.05).
Comparison of the surface roughness of composite specimens before and after the wear test revealed significant differences in both glazed Suprinity ( = 0.048) and Vita Mark II ( = 0.026) ceramics groups. The change in surface roughness after the wear test (compared with baseline) was significant in glazed ( = 0.000) and polished ( = 0.013) Vita Mark II and polished Suprinity ( = 0.037) ceramics, but this change was not significant in other ceramics ( > 0.05). The depth of wear after the wear test was not significantly different among the ceramic and composite subgroups ( > 0.05).
Assessment of depth of wear and surface roughness of composite specimens showed that the polishing kits of CAD-CAM ceramics can serve as a suitable alternative to reglazing.
本研究旨在评估计算机辅助设计-计算机辅助制造(CAD-CAM)陶瓷的抛光与上釉对相对的复合树脂磨损深度和表面粗糙度的影响。
本研究对40个Z250复合材料标本和40个CAD-CAM陶瓷标本进行,其中陶瓷标本包括Celtra Duo、Vita Mark II、e.max CAD和Vita Suprinity陶瓷。所有陶瓷标本在初次上釉后用细粒度车针进行粗化处理,以模拟临床环境中的调整表面。然后将它们随机分为两个亚组,分别进行再次上釉或抛光处理。所有复合材料和陶瓷标本在表面处理后及磨损试验前进行轮廓测量,并对结果进行定量记录。然后将复合材料标本在咀嚼模拟器中与陶瓷标本进行120,000次磨损循环,并用扫描仪测量磨损深度。数据采用重复测量双向方差分析(ANOVA)和单向ANOVA进行统计学分析(α = 0.05)。
磨损试验前后复合材料标本表面粗糙度的比较显示,在上釉的Suprinity( = 0.048)和Vita Mark II( = 0.026)陶瓷组中均存在显著差异。磨损试验后表面粗糙度的变化(与基线相比)在上釉的( = 0.000)和抛光的( = 0.013)Vita Mark II以及抛光的Suprinity( = 0.037)陶瓷中显著,但在其他陶瓷中不显著( > 0.05)。磨损试验后陶瓷和复合材料亚组之间的磨损深度无显著差异( > 0.05)。
对复合材料标本磨损深度和表面粗糙度的评估表明,CAD-CAM陶瓷的抛光套件可作为再次上釉的合适替代方案。