Feuille Colin, Sewell Justin L
Division of Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA.
Frontline Gastroenterol. 2023 Jun 29;15(1):14-20. doi: 10.1136/flgastro-2023-102410. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Training in how to effectively teach endoscopy is not included in most gastroenterology (GI) training programme curricula, yet many gastroenterologists are expected to teach endoscopy in their careers. Near-peer teaching could help senior GI trainees learn how to teach endoscopy and have benefits for junior trainees. We performed a qualitative study of a peer teaching initiative where senior trainees taught endoscopy to junior trainees under attending supervision.
We observed endoscopy sessions where the senior trainee taught a junior trainee under attending supervision, and then conducted individual interviews with the senior trainee teacher, junior trainee learner and attending to characterise affordances and barriers to learning. We performed thematic analysis on anonymised interview transcripts.
10 observations and 30 interviews were completed. Junior trainees reported senior trainees more approachable than attendings and explained concepts in more understandable ways. Senior trainees reported the teaching role improved skill at both teaching and performing endoscopy. Attendings reported positive impressions of the experience for senior trainees, and generally positive impressions with some reservations of the experience for junior trainees. A few barriers to learning were reported, but they were generally perceived as being outweighed by affordances. An area for improvement was setting clear expectations for senior trainee and attending roles before the session.
Near-peer endoscopy teaching was feasible and provided perceived affordances for junior and senior trainees alike, with few barriers. Incorporating formal training in teaching endoscopy into GI training programme curricula may produce both better endoscopists and better endoscopy teachers.
大多数胃肠病学(GI)培训项目课程中都没有关于如何有效教授内镜检查的培训内容,然而许多胃肠病学家在其职业生涯中都需要教授内镜检查。近伴教学有助于高级胃肠病学实习医生学习如何教授内镜检查,并对初级实习医生有益。我们对一项同伴教学计划进行了定性研究,该计划中高级实习医生在主治医生的监督下教授初级实习医生内镜检查。
我们观察了高级实习医生在主治医生监督下教授初级实习医生的内镜检查课程,然后分别对高级实习医生教师、初级实习医生学习者和主治医生进行了访谈,以描述学习的机会和障碍。我们对匿名的访谈记录进行了主题分析。
完成了10次观察和30次访谈。初级实习医生报告称,高级实习医生比主治医生更平易近人,讲解概念的方式更易懂。高级实习医生报告称,教学角色提高了教学和进行内镜检查的技能。主治医生对高级实习医生的体验给出了积极评价,对初级实习医生的体验总体评价积极,但有一些保留意见。报告了一些学习障碍,但总体认为机会大于障碍。一个有待改进的方面是在课程开始前明确对高级实习医生和主治医生角色的期望。
近伴内镜教学是可行的,为初级和高级实习医生都提供了可感知的机会,障碍较少。将内镜教学的正规培训纳入胃肠病学培训项目课程可能会培养出更好的内镜医生和更好的内镜检查教师。