Sezen Cenk, Šraj Mojca
Ondokuz Mayis University, Faculty of Engineering, 55139 Samsun, Turkey; Technical University of Dresden, Institute for Groundwater Management, 01069 Dresden, Germany.
University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Civil and Geodetic Engineering, Jamova 2, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Sci Total Environ. 2024 May 20;926:171684. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.171684. Epub 2024 Mar 18.
Hydrological modelling can be complex in nonhomogeneous catchments with diverse geological, climatic, and topographic conditions. In this study, an integrated conceptual model including the snow module with machine learning modelling approaches was implemented for daily rainfall-runoff modelling in mostly karst Ljubljanica catchment, Slovenia, which has heterogeneous characteristics and is potentially exposed to extreme events that make the modelling process more challenging and crucial. In this regard, the conceptual model CemaNeige Génie Rural à 6 paramètres Journalier (CemaNeige GR6J) was combined with machine learning models, namely wavelet-based support vector regression (WSVR) and wavelet-based multivariate adaptive regression spline (WMARS) to enhance modelling performance. In this study, the performance of the models was comprehensively investigated, considering their ability to forecast daily extreme runoff. Although CemaNeige GR6J yielded a very good performance, it overestimated low flows. The WSVR and WMARS models yielded poorer performance than the conceptual and hybrid models. The hybrid model approach improved the performance of the machine learning models and the conceptual model by revealing the linkage between variables and runoff in the conceptual model, which provided more accurate results for extreme flows. Accordingly, the hybrid models improved the forecasting performance of the maximum flows up to 40 % and 61 %, and minimum flows up to 73 % and 72 % compared to the CemaNeige GR6J and stand-alone machine learning models. In this regard, the hybrid model approach can enhance the daily rainfall-runoff modelling performance in nonhomogeneous and karst catchments where the hydrological process can be more complicated.
在具有不同地质、气候和地形条件的非均质流域中,水文建模可能会很复杂。在本研究中,针对斯洛文尼亚大部分为喀斯特地貌的卢布尔雅那卡河流域的日降雨径流建模,实施了一个包括雪模块和机器学习建模方法的综合概念模型,该流域具有非均质特征,且可能面临极端事件,这使得建模过程更具挑战性和至关重要性。在这方面,将概念模型“农村工程六参数日积雪模型(CemaNeige GR6J)”与机器学习模型相结合,即基于小波的支持向量回归(WSVR)和基于小波的多元自适应回归样条(WMARS),以提高建模性能。在本研究中,全面考察了这些模型预测日极端径流的能力。尽管CemaNeige GR6J表现出非常好的性能,但它高估了低流量。WSVR和WMARS模型的性能比概念模型和混合模型差。混合模型方法通过揭示概念模型中变量与径流之间的联系,提高了机器学习模型和概念模型的性能,为极端流量提供了更准确的结果。因此,与CemaNeige GR6J和独立的机器学习模型相比,混合模型将最大流量的预测性能提高了40%和61%,将最小流量的预测性能提高了73%和72%。在这方面,混合模型方法可以提高非均质和喀斯特流域的日降雨径流建模性能,在这些流域中水文过程可能更为复杂。