Esamai Fabian, Mwangi Ann, Nangami Mabel, Tabu John, Ayuku David, Were Edwin
Dept of Child Health and Paediatrics, School of Medicine College of Health Sciences Moi University, Kenya.
Dept of Behavioural Sciences, School of Medicine College of Health Sciences Moi University, P. O Box 4606, 30100 Eldoret, Kenya.
Dialogues Health. 2023 Apr 10;2:100133. doi: 10.1016/j.dialog.2023.100133. eCollection 2023 Dec.
Maternal and infant mortality are higher in low-income than in high-income countries due to weak health systems. The objective of this study was to improve access, utilization and quality of Maternal and Child Health care through a predesigned Enhanced Health Care System (EHC) that embodies the World Health Organization (WHO) pillars of the health system.
This study was conducted in two dispensaries in the Counties of Busia and Bungoma in Kenya as intervention sites and in four control clusters in Kakamega, Uasin Gishu, Trans Nzoia and Elgeyo Marakwet Counties. The study population was pregnant women and their children delivered over the study period in the intervention and control clusters.A quasi-experimental study design was used to conduct the study between 2015 and 2020 to compare the outcomes of the implementation of the EHC using the Find Link Treat and Retain (FLTR) strategy in one cluster, community owned initiatives in the other cluster and four control clusters at baseline and at the end of the study. A baseline survey was conducted in year one and an end line survey in the fifth year. Continuous data collection on maternal and childhood health indicators was done in all the six clusters and comparison made at the end of the study between the clusters.
We found a 26%, 10.3% and 0.8% increase in antenatal care (ANC) attendance in the intervention clusters of Obekai, Kabula and control clusters respectively. There was a 28.2%, 5.8% and 17.0% increase in attendance of 4+ ANC clinics of Obekai, Kabula and control clusters respectively. There was a 24% and 13% increase in Obekai and Kabula respectively in contraceptive use and a 2% decrease in contraceptive use in the control locations. There was a 38.2%, 25.6% and 34.7% increase in facility deliveries over the study period in Obekai, Kabula and control clusters respectively. There was a marked increase in immunization coverage in the intervention clusters of Obekai and Kabula compared to a significant decrease in control clusters for BCG, polio, pentavalent and measles.
In conclusion, use of the health systems approach in health care provision provides a holistic improvement in access and utilization of health services and in the improvement of health indicators.We do recommend that a systems approach be used in health services delivery to improve access, utilization and quality of health care provision at community and primary care levels.
由于卫生系统薄弱,低收入国家的孕产妇和婴儿死亡率高于高收入国家。本研究的目的是通过一个预先设计的强化卫生保健系统(EHC)来改善妇幼保健的可及性、利用率和质量,该系统体现了世界卫生组织(WHO)卫生系统的支柱。
本研究在肯尼亚布西亚县和邦戈马县的两个诊疗所作为干预地点进行,并在卡卡梅加、乌阿辛吉舒、特兰斯恩佐亚和埃尔盖约马拉奎特县的四个对照群组进行。研究人群为在干预和对照群组的研究期间分娩的孕妇及其子女。采用准实验研究设计,在2015年至2020年期间进行研究,以比较在一个群组中使用“查找、联系、治疗和留住”(FLTR)策略实施EHC的结果,另一个群组中的社区自主倡议以及四个对照群组在基线和研究结束时的情况。在第一年进行基线调查,在第五年进行终线调查。在所有六个群组中持续收集孕产妇和儿童健康指标数据,并在研究结束时对各群组进行比较。
我们发现,奥贝凯、卡布拉干预群组和对照群组的产前保健(ANC)就诊率分别提高了26%、10.3%和0.8%。奥贝凯、卡布拉和对照群组的4次及以上ANC诊所就诊率分别提高了28.2%、5.8%和17.0%。奥贝凯和卡布拉的避孕药具使用率分别提高了24%和13%,而对照地区的避孕药具使用率下降了2%。在研究期间,奥贝凯、卡布拉和对照群组的机构分娩率分别提高了38.2%、25.6%和34.7%。与对照群组中卡介苗、脊髓灰质炎、五价疫苗和麻疹疫苗接种率显著下降相比,奥贝凯和卡布拉干预群组的免疫接种覆盖率显著提高。
总之,在卫生保健提供中采用卫生系统方法可全面改善卫生服务的可及性和利用率,并改善健康指标。我们确实建议在卫生服务提供中采用系统方法,以提高社区和初级保健层面卫生保健提供的可及性、利用率和质量。