Chaurasia Sangita, Trivedi Anshuli, Ganvir Ruchi, Singh Saagar, Yadav Jayanthi, Malik Reeni, Choubal Sneha, Arora Arneet
Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, IND.
Department of Community Medicine, Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal, IND.
Cureus. 2024 Feb 21;16(2):e54630. doi: 10.7759/cureus.54630. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Introduction Various studies have linked suicidal behavior, stress, affective disorders, and dysregulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis resulting from chronic stress. Chronic stress has been shown to cause enlargement of the adrenal glands, altering their function and potentially leading to suicidal behaviors in individuals with depression. This study aimed to compare the histological changes in the adrenal glands of individuals who died by suicide with those who experienced sudden death. Suicide victims are exposed to chronic stress, while individuals with sudden deaths face acute stress related to the act of dying. Methods This analytical study, approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC), was conducted in the Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology at Gandhi Medical College, Bhopal. The study included 100 confirmed cases of suicide, irrespective of gender, aged 15-60 years, with notable autopsy findings, relevant history, no signs of decomposition, and varying survival periods (including immediate deaths within 24 hours). Additionally, 20 controls were selected, involving individuals who died suddenly from causes other than suicide within 24 hours of the incident. Informed consent was obtained using a prescribed proforma from relatives and the police. Histological examination slides of the adrenals were prepared and analyzed. Data were collected and statistically analyzed using GraphPad software and Epi Info 7. Results Capsular hemorrhage was observed in 98% of suicide cases and 40% of controls. Nodulation was present in 48% of suicidal cases and 20% of controls. Zonal extension of zona fasciculata was specific to chronic stress in suicidal cases. In 25% of suicidal cases, a prominent extension of the medulla was noted. Irregular thinning of zona glomerulosa with shrunken cells and increased nuclear density in 88% of cases were considered specific to chronic stress conditions and suicide, not observed in controls. Lipid depletion was observed in all suicidal cases, with diffuse depletion in 47% and focal depletion in 53% of cases. In contrast, 45% of those exposed to the acute stress of dying showed focal depletion, with none exhibiting diffuse depletion. Suicidal cases displayed dilated prominent sinusoids in all three zones and the adrenal medulla (98-99%), absent in controls. Adrenal hemorrhage and necrosis were specific to chronic stress conditions, with 7%, 8%, 32%, and 16% of cases showing hemorrhage in all three zones and adrenal medulla, respectively, and none in controls. Conclusion Histological changes observed in acute stress conditions included focal lipid depletion, capsular hemorrhage, nodular hyperplasia, and hemorrhage and necrosis with edema. However, the proportion and severity of these changes were lower than those observed in the suicidal group, suggesting that these findings may be considered non-specific for differentiating between acute and chronic stress.
引言 多项研究将自杀行为、压力、情感障碍以及慢性应激导致的下丘脑 - 垂体 - 肾上腺(HPA)轴功能失调联系起来。慢性应激已被证明会导致肾上腺增大,改变其功能,并可能导致抑郁症患者出现自杀行为。本研究旨在比较自杀死亡者与猝死个体肾上腺的组织学变化。自杀受害者面临慢性应激,而猝死个体则面临与死亡行为相关的急性应激。
方法 这项经机构伦理委员会(IEC)批准的分析性研究在博帕尔甘地医学院法医学与毒理学系进行。该研究纳入了100例确诊的自杀病例,不分性别,年龄在15至60岁之间,尸检结果显著,有相关病史,无腐败迹象,存活时间各异(包括24小时内的即刻死亡)。此外,选取了20名对照者,包括在事件发生后24小时内因非自杀原因突然死亡的个体。通过向亲属和警方使用规定的表格获取知情同意。制备并分析肾上腺的组织学检查切片。使用GraphPad软件和Epi Info 7收集数据并进行统计分析。
结果 在98%的自杀病例和40%的对照者中观察到包膜出血。48%的自杀病例和20%的对照者出现结节形成。束状带的带状延伸是自杀病例中慢性应激所特有的。在25%的自杀病例中,观察到髓质有明显延伸。88%的病例中,球状带不规则变薄,细胞萎缩且核密度增加,这被认为是慢性应激状态和自杀所特有的,在对照者中未观察到。所有自杀病例均观察到脂质耗竭,47%的病例为弥漫性耗竭,53%的病例为局灶性耗竭。相比之下,45%遭受急性死亡应激的个体表现为局灶性耗竭,无一人表现为弥漫性耗竭。自杀病例在所有三个区及肾上腺髓质均显示扩张明显的血窦(98 - 99%),对照者中未出现。肾上腺出血和坏死是慢性应激状态所特有的,分别有7%、8%、32%和16%的病例在所有三个区及肾上腺髓质出现出血,对照者中无出血情况。
结论 在急性应激状态下观察到的组织学变化包括局灶性脂质耗竭、包膜出血、结节性增生以及伴有水肿的出血和坏死。然而,这些变化的比例和严重程度低于自杀组,这表明这些发现可能被认为对于区分急性和慢性应激不具有特异性。