Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Nair Hospital Dental College, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Department of Public Health Dentistry, Sinhgad Dental College and Hospital, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
PeerJ. 2024 Mar 20;12:e16991. doi: 10.7717/peerj.16991. eCollection 2024.
Sex estimation is crucial to forensic examinations. In order to estimate sex, intact bones are used if the majority of bones are severely deformed and recovered in fragments. This study aims to analyze sexual dimorphism in intact maxillary sinuses using CBCT scanning to evaluate morphometric properties for sex identification.
A total of 318 subjects, consisting of 159 males and 159 females, aged between 20 and 60 years without sinus pathology were included in this diagnostic, retrospective cross-sectional study. Bilateral measurements of the volume, height, width, and length of the maxillary sinuses were obtained and compared to evaluate the differences between sexes. Subsequently, a descriptive analysis using mean and standard deviation was performed, followed by a comparison between sexes with a p-value being less than 0.05 and Student's t-test. Finally, a discriminant analysis was performed separately for the right and left maxillary sinuses.
Males and females showed statistically significant variations in the length, width, and volume of the maxillary sinuses. Specifically, on the right side, males had longer maxillary sinuses than females ( = 5.6203, < 0.0001). Meanwhile, on the left side, females had wider maxillary sinuses than males ( = 8.621, 0.0001). In addition, males had greater volumes of maxillary sinuses on the right ( = 6.373, < 0.0001) and left ( = 3.091, < 0.0001) sides than females. The results of the discriminant analysis showed that the left width parameter had the highest accuracy of sex estimation (74.21%), followed by the Right Length (70.07%) and left volume (66.66%) parameters. The left height parameter had the lowest accuracy of sex estimation (49.37%).
In forensic odontology, the volume of maxillary sinus can serve as a valid radiographic indicator of sex estimation.
性别鉴定对于法医检查至关重要。如果大多数骨骼严重变形并以碎片形式回收,则使用完整的骨骼进行性别鉴定。本研究旨在使用 CBCT 扫描分析完整上颌窦的性别二态性,以评估形态特征进行性别鉴定。
本诊断性回顾性横断面研究共纳入 318 名年龄在 20 至 60 岁之间、无鼻窦病变的 159 名男性和 159 名女性受试者。对双侧上颌窦的体积、高度、宽度和长度进行测量,并进行比较,以评估性别差异。随后,进行均值和标准差的描述性分析,然后进行性别比较,p 值小于 0.05,采用学生 t 检验。最后,分别对右侧和左侧上颌窦进行判别分析。
男性和女性的上颌窦长度、宽度和体积存在统计学显著差异。具体来说,在右侧,男性上颌窦长度大于女性(=5.6203,<0.0001)。而在左侧,女性上颌窦宽度大于男性(=8.621,0.0001)。此外,男性右侧(=6.373,<0.0001)和左侧(=3.091,<0.0001)上颌窦体积均大于女性。判别分析结果显示,左侧宽度参数的性别估计准确率最高(74.21%),其次是右侧长度(70.07%)和左侧体积(66.66%)参数。左侧高度参数的性别估计准确率最低(49.37%)。
在法医牙科学中,上颌窦体积可以作为性别估计的有效影像学指标。