Department of Veterinary Medicine, College of Veterinary Medicine, National Chung Hsing University, Taichung 40249, Taiwan.
Chronic Diseases and Health Promotion Research Center, Chang Gung University of Science and Technology, Chiayi 61363, Taiwan.
J Food Drug Anal. 2023 Dec 15;31(4):583-598. doi: 10.38212/2224-6614.3474.
Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are highly prevalent bacterial infections that pose significant health risks. Specific probiotic strains have been recommended for UTI control and management of antibiotic resistance. Otherwise, para-probiotics, defined as inactivated probiotic cells, offer potential advantages by minimizing risks associated with live microorganisms. However, the effectiveness of heat-killed probiotic strains against UTIs remains uncertain. Additionally, lactoferrin (LF), an iron-binding glycoprotein, exhibits immunomodulatory, antimicrobial, and anti-inflammatory properties. Recently, we had developed recombinant LF-expression probiotics, which can display considerate antibacterial activities against select food-borne pathogens in vitro. Thus, the present study aimed to evaluate the antibacterial activities of heat-killed natural and recombinant LF-expressing probiotics against UTIs in vitro and in vivo. Firstly, using in vitro assays, we assessed the antibacterial activity of heat-killed natural and recombinant LF-expressing probiotics against uropathogenic Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Among the tested probiotics, 10 heat-killed LF-expressing strains displayed superior antibacterial efficacy compared to 12 natural probiotics. Based on their potent in vitro activity, selected probiotics were formulated into three probiotic mixtures: viable probiotic mixture (LAB), heat-killed probiotic mixture (HK-LAB), and heat-killed LF-expressing probiotic mixture (HK-LAB/LF). To further evaluate the therapeutic potential of these probiotic mixtures in vivo, we established a murine model of UTIs by intraurethral administration of E. coli to 40 female C57BL/6JNarl mice on day 0. Subsequently, mice received oral gavage of placebo, LAB, HK-LAB, or HK-LAB/LF for 21 consecutive days (n = 8 per group). An additional control group (n = 8) received ampicillin treatment for 7 days. To assess protective effects against re-infection or UTI relapse, all mice were challenged with E. coli on day 22 and E. coli plus K. pneumoniae on day 25. Results from the murine UTI model demonstrated that placebo administration did not reduce bacteriuria throughout the experiment. Conversely, supplementation with ampicillin, HK-LAB/LF, HK-LAB, or LAB significantly (p < 0.05) reduced daily bacteriuria by 103 to 104-fold on days 1, 3, 5, and 14, respectively. Furthermore, all four therapeutic treatments improved the bacteriological cure rate (BCR) with varying levels of efficacy. For the 7-day treatment course, the BCR was 25% (placebo), 62.5% (ampicillin), 37.5% (LAB), 37.5% (HK-LAB), and 62.5% (HK-LAB/LF). For the 21-day treatment course, the BCR was 25% (placebo), 75% (ampicillin), 37.5% (LAB), 37.5% (HK-LAB), and 75% (HK-LAB/LF). Notably, HK-LAB and HK-LAB/LF demonstrated superior therapeutic efficacy compared to viable LAB in treating UTIs. Overall, regarding BCR, the three probiotic mixtures can provide benefits against UTI in mice, but ampicillin therapy remains the most efficient among the four treatments. Furthermore, there was no significant difference between pre- and post-challenge courses for the two instances of re-challenging uropathogens in all mice groups, as bacteriuria levels remained below 103 CFU/mL, implying that adaptive responses of mice may help reduce the risk of recurrent UTIs. In conclusion, our results provide new evidence that oral administration of heat-killed probiotic mixtures can confer significant therapeutic efficacy against UTIs in a murine model.
尿路感染(UTI)是一种高发的细菌性感染,会对健康造成重大威胁。已经推荐了特定的益生菌菌株来控制和管理 UTI 以及对抗抗生素耐药性。此外,副益生菌被定义为失活的益生菌细胞,通过最大限度地降低与活微生物相关的风险,提供了潜在的优势。然而,热灭活益生菌菌株对 UTI 的有效性仍然不确定。此外,乳铁蛋白(LF)是一种具有免疫调节、抗菌和抗炎特性的铁结合糖蛋白。最近,我们已经开发了重组 LF 表达益生菌,这些益生菌在体外对选择的食源性病原体具有相当的抗菌活性。因此,本研究旨在评估热灭活天然和重组 LF 表达益生菌对体外和体内 UTI 的抗菌活性。首先,通过体外试验,我们评估了热灭活天然和重组 LF 表达益生菌对尿路致病性大肠杆菌和肺炎克雷伯菌的抗菌活性。在所测试的益生菌中,10 株热灭活 LF 表达菌株的抗菌效果优于 12 株天然益生菌。基于其强大的体外活性,选择了一些益生菌制成三种益生菌混合物:活菌益生菌混合物(LAB)、热灭活益生菌混合物(HK-LAB)和热灭活 LF 表达益生菌混合物(HK-LAB/LF)。为了进一步评估这些益生菌混合物在体内治疗 UTI 的潜力,我们通过尿道内给予大肠杆菌的方法在 40 只雌性 C57BL/6JNarl 小鼠上建立了 UTI 模型,在第 0 天。随后,小鼠接受口服安慰剂、LAB、HK-LAB 或 HK-LAB/LF 连续 21 天(每组 8 只)。一个额外的对照组(n=8)接受氨苄西林治疗 7 天。为了评估对再感染或 UTI 复发的保护作用,所有小鼠在第 22 天和第 25 天接受大肠杆菌和肺炎克雷伯菌的联合挑战。来自小鼠 UTI 模型的结果表明,安慰剂给药并不能在整个实验过程中减少菌尿。相反,氨苄西林、HK-LAB/LF、HK-LAB 或 LAB 的补充显著(p<0.05)降低了第 1、3、5 和 14 天的每日菌尿量 103 至 104 倍。此外,所有四种治疗方法都提高了细菌学治愈率(BCR),具有不同的疗效水平。对于 7 天的治疗过程,BCR 为 25%(安慰剂)、62.5%(氨苄西林)、37.5%(LAB)、37.5%(HK-LAB)和 62.5%(HK-LAB/LF)。对于 21 天的治疗过程,BCR 为 25%(安慰剂)、75%(氨苄西林)、37.5%(LAB)、37.5%(HK-LAB)和 75%(HK-LAB/LF)。值得注意的是,与活菌 LAB 相比,HK-LAB 和 HK-LAB/LF 在治疗 UTI 方面具有更好的治疗效果。总体而言,就 BCR 而言,三种益生菌混合物在治疗小鼠 UTI 方面具有有益作用,但氨苄西林治疗仍然是四种治疗方法中最有效的。此外,在所有小鼠组中,两次重新挑战尿路病原体的前后治疗过程中,没有明显的差异,因为菌尿水平仍低于 103 CFU/mL,这表明小鼠的适应性反应可能有助于降低复发性 UTI 的风险。总之,我们的结果提供了新的证据,表明口服热灭活益生菌混合物可以在小鼠模型中对 UTI 产生显著的治疗效果。