McDaid Lisa, Belderson Pippa, Emery Joanne, Coleman Tim, Leonardi-Bee Jo, Naughton Felix
School of Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom.
Division of Primary Care, School of Medicine, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom.
PLOS Digit Health. 2024 Mar 27;3(3):e0000472. doi: 10.1371/journal.pdig.0000472. eCollection 2024 Mar.
Many pregnant smokers need support to quit successfully. In the United Kingdom, trained smoking cessation advisors deliver structured behavioural counselling alongside access to free nicotine replacement therapy (NRT); known as the 'Standard Treatment Programme' (STP). Pregnant smokers who access STP support are more likely to quit, but uptake is low. A digital intervention could be offered as an adjunct or alternative to existing STP support to increase cessation rates. However, there are few pregnancy-specific digital options routinely available and, among those that are, there is limited evidence of their effectiveness. This study investigated experts' views on the feasibility of translating the STP into a comprehensive digital intervention. Virtual group and individual interviews were undertaken with 37 experts (11 focus groups, 3 interviews) with a real-time voting activity in the focus groups to prompt discussion. Framework Analysis was applied to the data to examine themes and patterns. Experts were supportive of a digital translation of the STP and considered most behavioural counselling content to be transferable. However, replicating human-to-human accountability, empathy and the ability to go 'off-script' was thought more challenging. Suggestions for how this might be achieved included tailoring and personalisation, use of artificial intelligence tools, peer support and the option to escalate contact to a human advisor. Experts had mixed views on the role that exhaled breath carbon monoxide monitoring might have in a digital cessation intervention for pregnancy. Electronic provision of free NRT, and potentially e-cigarettes, without interpersonal support was generally well received. However, experts had concerns about it exacerbating low NRT adherence, governance issues (e.g. being accountable for the suitability of recommended products), and people's ability to misrepresent their eligibility. The STP was considered largely transferable to a digital intervention and potentially helpful for cessation in pregnancy, so merits further development and evaluation.
许多怀孕吸烟者需要获得支持才能成功戒烟。在英国,经过培训的戒烟顾问会提供结构化行为咨询,并提供免费的尼古丁替代疗法(NRT);这被称为“标准治疗方案”(STP)。获得STP支持的怀孕吸烟者更有可能戒烟,但接受率较低。可以提供数字干预措施作为现有STP支持的辅助手段或替代方案,以提高戒烟率。然而,常规可用的针对怀孕的数字选项很少,而且在这些选项中,其有效性的证据有限。本研究调查了专家对将STP转化为全面数字干预措施可行性的看法。对37名专家进行了虚拟小组和个人访谈(11个焦点小组,3次访谈),并在焦点小组中进行了实时投票活动以促进讨论。对数据应用框架分析来检查主题和模式。专家们支持将STP进行数字化转化,并认为大多数行为咨询内容是可转移的。然而,复制人与人之间的问责制、同理心以及“脱稿”能力被认为更具挑战性。关于如何实现这一点的建议包括定制和个性化、使用人工智能工具、同伴支持以及将联系升级为人工顾问的选项。专家们对呼出一氧化碳监测在怀孕数字戒烟干预中可能发挥的作用看法不一。在没有人际支持的情况下电子提供免费NRT以及可能的电子烟总体上受到好评。然而,专家们担心这会加剧NRT依从性低、治理问题(例如对推荐产品的适用性负责)以及人们虚报资格的能力。STP在很大程度上被认为可转化为数字干预措施,对孕期戒烟可能有帮助,因此值得进一步开发和评估。