Chang Jennifer, Bliss Logan, Angelov Nikola, Glick Aaron
Department of Periodontics and Dental Hygiene, School of Dentistry, The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, Houston, Texas, USA.
School of Dentistry, The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, Houston, Texas, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2024 Jul;88(7):933-939. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13524. Epub 2024 Mar 28.
With the increasing prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI) and the significant research gap in the application of AI within dentistry, this study aimed to (1) evaluate the efficiency and accuracy of dental students in full-mouth radiograph series (FMS) mounting with and without AI assistance, and (2) assess dental students' perceptions of AI in clinical education to address the impact of AI in dental education.
An AI-based interface for mounting radiographs on FMS templates was designed and implemented in the study. Forty third-year dental students were randomly assigned to control and test groups. The control group manually mounted FMS radiographs, while the test group reviewed AI-pre-mounted radiographs for adjustments. Students' performance in efficiency and accuracy was evaluated. Pre- and post-study surveys were conducted to gauge students' confidence levels and opinions regarding the usefulness of the AI-assisted program.
The test group (using AI) demonstrated significantly faster radiograph mounting times than the control group (manual) (p < 0.05). Accuracy was lower in the test groups, when comparing AI-assisted and manual mounting of FMS (p < 0.01). Self-confidence and confidence in AI were consistent between the control and test groups, both before and after the study.
Students with AI presented with a decreased accuracy in FMS radiograph mounting. Therefore, AI automation could potentially have negative impacts in a learning environment with inexperienced clinicians.
随着人工智能(AI)的日益普及以及牙科领域在AI应用方面存在显著研究差距,本研究旨在:(1)评估牙科学生在有无AI辅助情况下进行全口系列X光片(FMS)装片的效率和准确性;(2)评估牙科学生在临床教育中对AI的看法,以探讨AI在牙科教育中的影响。
本研究设计并实现了一个基于AI的将X光片装在FMS模板上的界面。40名三年级牙科学生被随机分为对照组和试验组。对照组手动进行FMSX光片装片,而试验组检查由AI预装片的X光片以进行调整。评估了学生在效率和准确性方面的表现。在研究前后进行了调查,以衡量学生对AI辅助程序有用性的信心水平和看法。
试验组(使用AI)的X光片装片时间明显快于对照组(手动装片)(p < 0.05)。在比较AI辅助装片和手动装片FMS时,试验组的准确性较低(p < 0.01)。在研究前后,对照组和试验组在对自身的信心以及对AI的信心方面保持一致。
使用AI的学生在FMSX光片装片时准确性降低。因此,AI自动化在临床经验不足的学习环境中可能产生负面影响。