Shaw W C, Rees G, Dawe M, Charles C R
Am J Orthod. 1985 Jan;87(1):21-6. doi: 10.1016/0002-9416(85)90170-8.
The purpose of the study was to determine whether the social attractiveness of a young adult would be influenced by his or her dentofacial appearance. Black and white photographs of an attractive male, an unattractive male, an attractive female, and an unattractive female were obtained and modified so that, for each face, five different photographic versions were available. In each version, the face was standardized except that a different dentofacial arrangement was demonstrated. These were normal incisors, prominent incisors, absence of upper left lateral incisor, severely crowded incisors, and unilateral cleft lip. Eight hundred young adults were shown one of the twenty photographs and asked to estimate the represented individual's social characteristics along a number of bipolar scales. Each photograph was viewed by a different group of forty young adults, equally divided as to sex. Their impressions of the depicted individuals' social attractiveness were recorded on visual analogue scales. The experimental procedure was such that the effect and interaction of different levels of facial attractiveness, different dentofacial arrangements, sex of the photographed individual, and sex of the judge could be analyzed. Faces displaying a normal incisor relationship gained the most favorable ratings for eight of the ten characteristics examined, and in four of these differences across the range of dental conditions were statistically significant. These were perceived friendliness, social class, popularity, and intelligence. The prominent incisor condition was rated highest for compliance and honesty, while the condition representing a unilateral cleft consistently attracted low ratings. Background facial attractiveness of either the male or female stimuli was often more assertive than the individual dental condition.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
该研究的目的是确定年轻人的社会吸引力是否会受到其牙颌面外观的影响。获取了一位有吸引力的男性、一位无吸引力的男性、一位有吸引力的女性和一位无吸引力的女性的黑白照片,并进行修改,以便每张脸都有五个不同的照片版本。在每个版本中,除了展示不同的牙颌面排列外,面部均进行了标准化处理。这些排列分别是正常切牙、突出切牙、左上侧切牙缺失、严重拥挤切牙和单侧唇裂。向800名年轻人展示这20张照片中的一张,并要求他们根据一些两极量表来估计照片中人物的社会特征。每组40名年轻人观看一张不同的照片,男女各半。他们对所描绘人物社会吸引力的印象记录在视觉模拟量表上。实验程序能够分析不同面部吸引力水平、不同牙颌面排列、被拍摄者性别以及评判者性别的影响和相互作用。在检查的十个特征中,显示正常切牙关系的面部在其中八个特征上获得了最有利的评分,并且在这八个特征中的四个特征上,不同牙齿状况下的差异具有统计学意义。这些特征包括被感知到的友好度、社会阶层、受欢迎程度和智力。突出切牙的情况在顺从性和诚实度方面评分最高,而代表单侧唇裂的情况一直获得较低评分。男性或女性刺激物的背景面部吸引力往往比个体牙齿状况更具决定性。(摘要截取自250词)