Section of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, San Francisco Veterans Affairs Health Care System, San Francisco, California, USA.
Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine, San Francisco, California, USA.
Pacing Clin Electrophysiol. 2024 May;47(5):642-649. doi: 10.1111/pace.14912. Epub 2024 Mar 31.
Remote monitoring (RM) of pacemakers and implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICDs) is a Class 1, Level of Evidence A recommendation because of its multitude of clinical benefits. However, RM adherence rates are suboptimal, precluding patients from achieving these benefits. There is a need for direct-to-patient efforts to improve adherence.
In this national randomized, controlled trial conducted in the Veterans Health Administration (VHA), 2120 patients with a pacemaker or ICD who had not sent an RM transmission for ≥1 year (and usually ≥3 years) while under VHA care for their device were randomly assigned to be mailed a postcard (n = 1076) or a detailed letter (n = 1044). The postcard described what RM does and its key benefits (reduced mortality and fewer in-person visits). The letter provided a similar message but included more details about RM benefits and the process. The primary outcome was an RM transmission sent within 90 days of mailing, and a secondary outcome was an RM transmission sent within 365 days.
The primary outcome was achieved in 121 (11.3%) in the postcard and 96 patients (9.2%) in the letter group (p = .12). The secondary outcome was achieved in 266 (24.7%) and 239 (22.9%), respectively (p = .32).
This randomized trial showed no significant difference in the proportion of chronically non-adherent patients who sent an RM transmission after receiving a low-cost postcard or a detailed, higher-cost letter encouraging their participation in RM. However, as only a minority of patients responded to either, further work is needed to engage patients in the life-saving benefits of RM.
远程监测(RM)起搏器和植入式心脏复律除颤器(ICD)是一级证据 A 类推荐,因为它有很多临床益处。然而,RM 的依从率并不理想,使患者无法获得这些益处。需要直接针对患者的努力来提高依从性。
在退伍军人健康管理局(VHA)进行的这项全国性随机对照试验中,2120 名起搏器或 ICD 患者在 VHA 接受设备治疗期间,未发送 RM 传输>1 年(通常>3 年),随机分配邮寄明信片(n=1076)或详细信件(n=1044)。明信片描述了 RM 的作用及其主要益处(降低死亡率和减少就诊次数)。信件提供了类似的信息,但包括了更多关于 RM 益处和流程的细节。主要结果是在邮寄后 90 天内发送 RM 传输,次要结果是在 365 天内发送 RM 传输。
明信片组中有 121 例(11.3%)达到主要结局,信件组中有 96 例(9.2%)达到主要结局(p=0.12)。次要结局分别在 266 例(24.7%)和 239 例(22.9%)中达到(p=0.32)。
这项随机试验表明,在接受低成本明信片或详细、高成本信件鼓励参与 RM 后,慢性不依从患者发送 RM 传输的比例没有显著差异。然而,由于只有少数患者对任何一种方法做出反应,因此需要进一步努力使患者参与 RM 的救命益处。