Maheshwari Sagar, Thomas Joel, Kuber Rajesh, Arkar Rahul, Lamghare Purnachandra, Avhad Madhuree, Tharmalingam Thulasi, Abraham Karen, Kharat Amit, Bhamare Dhammapal, Thomas Julie
Radiology, Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals NHS Trust, London, GBR.
Radiology, Dr. D. Y. (Dnyandeo Yashwantrao) Patil Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Pune, IND.
Cureus. 2024 Mar 3;16(3):e55463. doi: 10.7759/cureus.55463. eCollection 2024 Mar.
Background Over time, there has been a noticeable increase in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries. The current imperative is to anticipate predisposing factors and proactively prevent ACL injuries. The occurrence of ACL injuries has been linked to diverse factors associated with the morphology of the distal femur. Objectives Through this study, we aim to compare the anatomic variables of distal femur morphology such as notch width (NW), bicondylar width (BW), notch entrance width (NEW), and notch width index (NWI) between patients with ACL injuries and non-injured patients using MRI. We also aim to make a comparison of these factors between male and female genders to assess the gender variability. Material and methods A retrospective case-control study was conducted amongst patients who underwent MRI Knee scan for clinical suspicion of internal derangement during the study period. We selected the first 125 individuals who were found to have ACL injury in the MRI scans and selected another 125 individuals who had an intact ACL in the scans, to serve as controls in the study. Demographic information was retrieved from the hospital's electronic records, and the assessment of NW, NWI, BW, and NEW was conducted through a review of MRI sequences. They were then compared between the cases and control groups, as well as between male and female genders. Results The ACL-injured group exhibited statistically significant reductions in NW and NWI. While 17.39 mm was the mean NW among cases, 17.86 was the mean value among controls. Similarly, the mean NWI was 0.25 among patients with ACL injuries and 0.27 among controls. Gender-based comparisons also revealed statistically significant differences in NW and NWI measurements, where females were reported to have comparatively lower measurements. The mean NW for males and females in the injured group were 18.26 mm and 15.40 mm, respectively, while it was 18.71 mm and 16.90 mm, respectively, in the control group. In the case of NEW, males in the injured group had a slightly higher value (21.33 mm) than the controls (20.65). Females on the other hand exhibited a lower mean value of NEW in ACL-injured group (18.51 mm) in comparison to the non-injured (18.79 mm). BW did not seem to show a significant difference between the two groups. Conclusions In the studied population, ACL injuries demonstrated a higher occurrence in individuals with a narrow femoral intercondylar NWI. If any of these characteristics are identified in an MRI, it may be helpful to identify individuals who are at a higher risk of developing ACL injuries and may thereby help in planning preventative strategies.
背景 随着时间的推移,前交叉韧带(ACL)损伤显著增加。当前的当务之急是预测诱发因素并积极预防ACL损伤。ACL损伤的发生与股骨远端形态的多种因素有关。
目的 通过本研究,我们旨在使用MRI比较ACL损伤患者与未受伤患者之间股骨远端形态的解剖学变量,如髁间窝宽度(NW)、双髁宽度(BW)、髁间窝入口宽度(NEW)和髁间窝宽度指数(NWI)。我们还旨在比较这些因素在男性和女性之间的差异,以评估性别变异性。
材料和方法 对研究期间因临床怀疑内部紊乱而接受膝关节MRI扫描的患者进行了一项回顾性病例对照研究。我们选择了MRI扫描中发现的前125例ACL损伤患者,并选择了另外125例扫描中ACL完整的患者作为研究对照。从医院电子记录中获取人口统计学信息,并通过回顾MRI序列对NW、NWI、BW和NEW进行评估。然后将它们在病例组和对照组之间以及男性和女性之间进行比较。
结果 ACL损伤组的NW和NWI在统计学上有显著降低。病例组的平均NW为17.39mm,对照组为17.86mm。同样,ACL损伤患者的平均NWI为0.25,对照组为0.27。基于性别的比较还显示NW和NWI测量值在统计学上有显著差异,据报道女性的测量值相对较低。损伤组男性和女性的平均NW分别为18.26mm和15.40mm,而对照组分别为18.71mm和16.90mm。在NEW方面,损伤组男性的值(21.33mm)略高于对照组(20.65mm)。另一方面,ACL损伤组女性的NEW平均值(18.51mm)低于未受伤组(18.79mm)。两组之间BW似乎没有显著差异。
结论 在研究人群中,ACL损伤在股骨髁间NWI狭窄的个体中发生率较高。如果在MRI中发现这些特征中的任何一个,可能有助于识别发生ACL损伤风险较高的个体,从而有助于制定预防策略。