Bhattarai Ashbin, Subedi Dipendra, Bhandari Jyotsna, Homagain Sushan, Paudel Suruchi, Ghimire Jeevan
Dhading Hospital, Nilkantha Municipality, Dhading.
Siddhartha City Hospital, Bhairawaha, Nepal.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2024 Feb 28;86(4):2330-2334. doi: 10.1097/MS9.0000000000001874. eCollection 2024 Apr.
Barton fractures are distal radius fractures that extend through the dorsal aspect of the articular surface, with associated dislocation of the radiocarpal joint. They are extremely unstable and require open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). Delayed presentation is often encountered with difficulty in achieving reduction, and more extensive surgery may be needed. Here, we present a case of a 3-week-old neglected volar Barton fracture of the right wrist treated with the conventional method in a rural setting.
A 32-year-old gentleman was initially denied surgical intervention for a distal radius fracture he sustained after a motor vehicle accident and was discharged with a long arm slab plus analgesics represented in the outpatient department and agreed upon surgical intervention after his condition did not improve with conservative treatment. The trans-FCR (flexor carpi radialis) approach was used for surgery under the brachial plexus block. The fragment was reduced by applying pressure volarly into the distal radius and was confirmed with imaging. A K-wire (Kirschner) was used to temporarily hold the fragment. A volar distal radius locking plate was used to buttress the distal fragment. Final fixation was made using altogether six screws. The wrist was splinted in a short dorsal slab. Skin sutures were removed after 2 weeks, and an active assisted range of motion of the wrist was begun after 6 postoperative weeks.
Volar Barton is an uncommon subset of intra-articular fractures and typically results from damage sustained at high speeds. The general agreement for neglected fractures is that 'fractures that are not handled or mishandled resulting in treatment delay, worsening of the fracture and even a disability' are to be considered neglected fractures. Rebuilding the damaged anatomy properly and enabling a prompt, problem-free recovery of hand function are the main objectives of treatment. As conservative therapy is often ineffective and rife with side effects, including early osteoarthrosis, deformity, subluxation, and instability, stabilization and anatomic reduction by surgery is the key to managing these fractures. Plating is one of the therapeutic modalities among various therapeutic modalities depicted in the literature that enables shorter time of immobilization and early restoration of wrist function through direct anatomic repair and stable internal fixation. In our case, the callus was relatively immature, and the original fracture site could easily be cleared. Also, there was no significant soft tissue shortening, and the volar fragment had not migrated proximally, in contrast to what is expected in prolonged neglected cases. Hence, the intraoperative reduction was possible, and the fracture was fixed with a volar locking plate as usual.
Given the modest tissue shortening and young callus, such cases may be treated as conventional Barton's fractures and managed using conventional means of fixation with locking buttress plates. However, it makes sense to prepare for potential malreduction by carrying K wires and wrist distractions. To restore complete function to the injured wrist, adequate physiotherapy and postoperative splinting are essential components of postoperative rehabilitation.
巴顿骨折是桡骨远端骨折,骨折线延伸至关节面背侧,伴有桡腕关节脱位。此类骨折极不稳定,需要切开复位内固定(ORIF)。就诊延迟时,复位往往困难,可能需要更广泛的手术。在此,我们报告一例在农村地区采用传统方法治疗的3周龄右腕掌侧被忽视的巴顿骨折病例。
一名32岁男性在机动车事故后因桡骨远端骨折,最初未接受手术干预,出院时佩戴长臂石膏并服用镇痛药,门诊随访。经保守治疗病情未改善后,同意接受手术干预。在臂丛神经阻滞下采用经桡侧腕屈肌(FCR)入路进行手术。通过向桡骨远端掌侧施加压力使骨折块复位,影像学检查确认复位情况。使用克氏针临时固定骨折块。使用掌侧桡骨远端锁定钢板支撑远端骨折块。最终共使用6枚螺钉进行固定。腕关节用短背侧石膏托固定。术后2周拆除皮肤缝线,术后6周开始进行腕关节主动辅助活动度训练。
掌侧巴顿骨折是关节内骨折的一种少见类型,通常由高速损伤所致。对于被忽视骨折的普遍共识是,“未得到处理或处理不当导致治疗延迟、骨折情况恶化甚至残疾的骨折”应被视为被忽视骨折。正确重建受损解剖结构并使手部功能迅速、顺利恢复是治疗的主要目标。由于保守治疗往往无效且副作用众多,包括早期骨关节炎、畸形、半脱位和不稳定,手术稳定及解剖复位是治疗这些骨折的关键。钢板固定是文献中描述的多种治疗方式之一,通过直接解剖修复和稳定的内固定,可缩短固定时间并早期恢复腕关节功能。在我们的病例中,骨痂相对不成熟,原骨折部位易于清理。此外,与长期被忽视病例不同,软组织无明显短缩,掌侧骨折块未向近端移位。因此,术中能够进行复位,并像往常一样用掌侧锁定钢板固定骨折。
鉴于软组织短缩程度较轻且骨痂较年轻,此类病例可按传统巴顿骨折治疗,采用锁定支撑钢板的传统固定方法。然而,携带克氏针并准备好腕关节牵引以应对可能的复位不良是有必要的。为使受伤腕关节恢复完全功能,充分的物理治疗和术后石膏固定是术后康复的重要组成部分。