School of Medicine, University of Murcia, Murcia, Spain.
Department of General and Digestive Surgery, University Hospital Morales Meseguer, Murcia, Spain.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Apr 5;24(1):376. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05362-w.
Non-Technical Skills (NTS) are cognitive, social, and personal resource skills that are crucial in complex and high-risk environments. The aims of our research are to determine the prevalence and content of NTS in the surgical rotation teaching guides of the Medicine Degree programs in Spanish Universities, to identify the most prevalent types and subtypes of NTS, and to analyze factors associated with the prevalence of surgical NTS in Medical Schools in Spain.
Descriptive observational cross-sectional study involving the identification and collection of competencies outlined in the surgical rotation teaching guides of Spanish Medical Schools. Information regarding university performance was obtained from the Foundation for Knowledge and Development Ranking webpage. The "Non-Technical Skills for Surgeons" (NOTSS) system was used to classify each competency in the teaching guides as NTS (categories and elements) and technical skills. Disagreements were resolved through group consensus.
A total of 1,846 competencies were analyzed in surgical rotations of the Medicine Degree programs across 40 Spanish Universities, with 99 competencies identified as surgical NTS, accounting for 5% of the total. The most frequently identified surgical NTS were "Decision Making" (46%), "Communication & Teamwork" (25%), and "Leadership" (19%). Additionally, several NOTSS were not identified in any institution. Public universities and those including a greater number of competencies had a higher rate of surgical NTS competencies, and we did not find a correlation between surgical NTS competencies and quality indices of University Centers.
There is a limited presence of surgical NTS in the educational plans of Spanish Universities.
非技术技能(NTS)是认知、社交和个人资源技能,在复杂和高风险环境中至关重要。我们研究的目的是确定西班牙大学医学学位课程的外科轮转教学指南中 NTS 的流行程度和内容,确定最常见的 NTS 类型和亚型,并分析与西班牙医学院外科 NTS 流行相关的因素。
描述性观察性横断面研究,包括确定和收集西班牙医学院外科轮转教学指南中概述的能力。有关大学表现的信息来自知识与发展基金会排名网页。使用“外科医生的非技术技能”(NOTSS)系统将教学指南中的每项能力分类为 NTS(类别和要素)和技术技能。通过小组共识解决分歧。
共分析了 40 所西班牙大学的医学学位课程外科轮转中的 1846 项能力,其中有 99 项被确定为外科 NTS,占总数的 5%。最常被识别的外科 NTS 是“决策”(46%)、“沟通与团队合作”(25%)和“领导力”(19%)。此外,在任何机构都没有发现一些 NOTSS。公立大学和包含更多能力的机构外科 NTS 能力更高,我们没有发现外科 NTS 能力与大学中心质量指数之间存在相关性。
西班牙大学的教育计划中外科 NTS 的存在有限。