Muhsin Sayyed Mohamed, Arab Shaima Zohair, Chin Alexis Heng Boon
Department of Fiqh and Uṣūl al-Fiqh, International Islamic University Malaysia, Gombak, Malaysia.
Singapore Fertility and IVF Consultancy Pvt Ltd., Singapore.
Asian Bioeth Rev. 2023 Oct 14;16(2):223-232. doi: 10.1007/s41649-023-00258-1. eCollection 2024 Apr.
In recent years, preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) of IVF embryos have gained much traction in clinical assisted reproduction for preventing various genetic defects, including Down syndrome. However, such genetic tests inevitably reveal the sex of IVF embryos by identifying the sex (X and Y) chromosomes. In many countries with less stringent IVF regulations, information on the sex of embryos that are tested to be genetically normal is readily shared with patients. This would thus present Muslim patients with unintended opportunities for sex selection based on personal or social biases without any pressing need or valid medical reason. Additionally, there are other patients who claim using PGT for preventing genetic defects as a pretext or "convenient excuse," with a secret intention to do sex selection when it is banned in their home country. Currently, non-medical sex selection is a highly-controversial and hotly debated issue in Islam, because there is generally a strong preference for having sons over daughters due to widespread cultural norms of elderly parents depending on their sons for financial support, as well as the need for male heirs to continue the family lineage within the backdrop of local patriarchal cultures. There is a risk of gender imbalance and social disequilibrium occurring in Islamic societies due to prevalent sex selection. Hence, the question is whether opportunistic sex selection with PGT would contravene Islamic ethics and principles, which will thus be discussed here.
近年来,体外受精(IVF)胚胎的植入前基因检测(PGT)在临床辅助生殖中得到了广泛应用,用于预防包括唐氏综合征在内的各种基因缺陷。然而,这种基因检测不可避免地会通过识别性(X和Y)染色体来揭示IVF胚胎的性别。在许多试管婴儿监管不太严格的国家,经检测基因正常的胚胎的性别信息很容易就会告知患者。这就会给穆斯林患者带来基于个人或社会偏见进行性别选择的机会,而没有任何迫切需求或合理的医学理由。此外,还有其他患者以PGT预防基因缺陷为借口或“便利的托词”,在其本国被禁止进行性别选择时,暗中企图进行性别选择。目前,非医学的性别选择在伊斯兰教中是一个极具争议且备受热议的问题,因为由于普遍的文化规范,年迈的父母通常更依赖儿子提供经济支持,以及在当地父权文化背景下需要男性继承人延续家族血脉,所以普遍存在重男轻女的倾向。由于普遍存在性别选择,伊斯兰社会存在性别失衡和社会失衡的风险。因此,问题在于利用PGT进行机会主义的性别选择是否会违背伊斯兰伦理和原则,本文将对此进行讨论。