Chukhrova Nataliya, Johannssen Arne
Faculty of Business Administration University of Hamburg Hamburg Germany.
Int J Intell Syst. 2021 Jun;36(6):2922-2963. doi: 10.1002/int.22407. Epub 2021 Apr 7.
The sign test is one of the most popular nonparametric tests for location problems and allows testing for any quantile of a population. However, the common sign test has serious drawbacks such as loss of information by considering solely signs of observations but not their magnitudes, various problems related to handling of ties in the data, and the lack of embedding uncertainty regarding the fraction of underlying quantile. To address these issues, we present an extended sign test based on fuzzy categories and fuzzy formulated hypotheses that improves the generality, versatility, and practicability of the common sign test. This generalized test procedure is neat in theory and practice and avoids disadvantages that are often associated with fuzzy tests (e.g., a considerably higher complexity of the underlying model, a fuzzy test decision, and a possibilistic instead of a probabilistic interpretation of test results). In addition, we perform a comprehensive case study on COVID-19 in HIV-infected individuals with a focus on human body temperature and related measurement problems. The results of the study clearly indicate that fuzzy categories and fuzzy hypotheses improve the performance of the sign test.
符号检验是用于位置问题的最流行的非参数检验之一,可用于检验总体的任何分位数。然而,普通的符号检验存在严重缺陷,例如仅考虑观测值的符号而不考虑其大小会导致信息丢失,处理数据中的 ties 存在各种问题,以及缺乏关于基础分位数比例的嵌入不确定性。为了解决这些问题,我们提出了一种基于模糊类别和模糊表述假设的扩展符号检验,它提高了普通符号检验的通用性、多功能性和实用性。这种广义检验程序在理论和实践上都很简洁,避免了通常与模糊检验相关的缺点(例如,基础模型的复杂性大大增加、模糊的检验决策以及对检验结果的可能性而非概率解释)。此外,我们对感染 HIV 的个体中的 COVID-19 进行了全面的案例研究,重点关注人体体温及相关测量问题。研究结果清楚地表明,模糊类别和模糊假设提高了符号检验的性能。